Do The Good Buys/Loans Outweigh The Bad Buys/Loans

[waggadaddy]

How the hell has Ramage been a positive?????? I think he has been a massive let down!!! I haven't seen someone with such bad distribution of a ball at the club since Paul Bruce!!! i'll be honest I was quite happy when we signed him as I thought he always looked quite solid for Newcastle if not spetacular! I also agree that on the whole Mahon has been a positive....

[Half Empty]

My list differs slightly.

Positive

Buzsacky- On the basis of his first season with us alone.
Gorkss- I would say positive but has had a dodgey start this season.
Leigertwood- Just about makes it here because of some of the goals he's scored. And purely because when we sell him, we are likely to get more than the 900k we paid for him.
Routledge- Based on this season, perhaps the best signing we have made!
Tarrabt- Yes!
Connolly- Absolutely.
Cerny- Best keeper we have had in ages.
Vine- Based on his early form and if he can recapture it, yes.
Hogan- Young, hungry and gifted, YES!
Lopez- Ok so we dont have him any more, but he was quality when he was with us!


Negative

Miller (loan)
Lee (loan)
Mahon
Ageymang
Helguson
Alberti
Delaney (sold)
Hall
Cook- Never fit, and even when he is playing, he's past it. NO.
Ledesma
Parejo

Undecided

Heaton
Faurlin
Pellicori
Simpson
Borrowdale