Mackie told he can go

[SuperHoopNik]

He CAN cut it in the Premier league and would be a bad decision to let him go...IMO.

[stainrodisalegend]

Mackie was brilliant in the Championship, DJ is a top Championship striker. I know people won't agree with me but IMO its a mistake letting Mackie leave IF true because then we've got to sign a Championship right midfielder IF we go down & we won't find many better then Mackie

Brilliant? Not sure about that. If by brilliant you mean scoring goals then yes he started out like a house on fire for his first eight games or so, just as Agyman did. But by Christmas he was fading fast. Our promotion bid was starting to stutter and only picked up again when Mackie was replaced by Routledge, who is twice the player. Yes he has a great attitude and has given us pride and some very, very special moments (notably Liverpool at home last year, and robbing the ball from the Palace defender to play in Adel to score away to Palace a couple of years ago being two of my great memories of him) but if fans take off their rose tinted spectacles for a minute surely they would admit he has been found badly wanting in the skill department.

The key phrase in your post was "brilliant IN THE CHAMPIONSHIP". Well Harry is trying to keep us in the Prem, and must have decided that he isn't good enough to be part of the 25 for that fight.

[stainrodisalegend]

£3m, what's that gonna buy us to replace a person who WANTS to fight for the right to stay in the prem and if the unthinkable happens will be bang on it to get us back up

Odemwinge - proven prem striker who can score and create goals.

[Del]

Brilliant? Not sure about that. If by brilliant you mean scoring goals then yes he started out like a house on fire for his first eight games or so, just as Agyman did. But by Christmas he was fading fast. Our promotion bid was starting to stutter and only picked up again when Mackie was replaced by Routledge, who is twice the player. Yes he has a great attitude and has given us pride and some very, very special moments (notably Liverpool at home last year, and robbing the ball from the Palace defender to play in Adel to score away to Palace a couple of years ago being two of my great memories of him) but if fans take off their rose tinted spectacles for a minute surely they would admit he has been found badly wanting in the skill department.

The key phrase in your post was "brilliant IN THE CHAMPIONSHIP". Well Harry is trying to keep us in the Prem, and must have decided that he isn't good enough to be part of the 25 for that fight.

Spot on.

[madara]

I think Park wants to stay and that HR thinks Park is a useful player.

[DeepcutHoop]

Mistake to sell him, he's very, very useful from the bench to add some drive when needed.

[Ginger Ninja]

i cant help but get the feeling if he does go it'll come back to bite us in the #### at some point.
same with dj.

[stainrodisalegend]

I think Park wants to stay and that HR thinks Park is a useful player.

every manager has their blind spots i guess...

[SuperHoopNik]

I think Park wants to stay and that HR thinks Park is a useful player.

I reckon Fernandes told Hughes and now Redknapp that Park has to play every game if fit. Either that or it's in his contract. I can't imagine that MH and HR actually rates him to play him every game when he fails to impress week in week out.

[QPRDave]

i cant help but get the feeling if he does go it'll come back to bite us in the #### at some point.
same with dj.

Agree he will.........Would like to see us go for Phillips or Ince or both at Blackpool, if this story is true.

[vblockranger]

I reckon Fernandes told Hughes and now Redknapp that Park has to play every game if fit. Either that or it's in his contract. I can't imagine that Redknapp and Hughes actually rated him to play every game when he fails to impress week in week out.

agree...Park has been terrible for QPR since he came. His legs have gone it looks like, if he was a horse he would have been put down by now. Week in and week out its the same sh1t from him.

[stainrodisalegend]

Mistake to sell him, he's very, very useful from the bench to add some drive when needed.

its a fair comment. wd certainly prefer him in he 25 than ephraim. but if harry does have 15m to spend this window, and that will go on remy and rolando and he then needs the money to buy ottemwinge (I'm speculating, I don't know for sure) then think we have to back Harry's judgement. He's been fairly clear that if we want decent first team arrivals we are going to have to off-load some assets.

[Del]

Mistake to sell him, he's very, very useful from the bench to add some drive when needed.

Drive into opponents as he tries to bundle his way past them you mean.

[Rangers77]

agree...Park has been terrible for QPR since he came. His legs have gone it looks like, if he was a horse he would have been put down by now. Week in and week out its the same sh1t from him.

Harry has the tool's number. That's why he subbed him. And he'll have heard the fans boo Park loud and clear. He'll not feature again this season and will hopefully follow Anton on a plane somewhere.

[Mattyqpr]

Can't believe people want kranjcar! He'll be an absolute liability for a relegation dog fight.

I like Mackie but for that price it would be good business.

I think we need to suck it up this window and pay over inflated prices for proven premier league players.

Moaning over an extra few million in our position is silly with the huge financial package next season.

Danny Simpson and Jonus Olsson would cost around £9-10 million and they would be perfect.

Livermore on loan and Odemwingie for £3.5 million.

Kenwynne Jones and Danny Graham for £9 million.

Around £22 million spent for 6 proven premier league performers would be excellent business.