Just back, my take.

[Ginger Ninja]

We would have got at least a point today (and deservedly so) if Stephane Mbia hadn't been so bloody stupid. Sparky said all the indiscipline would be stamped out, where?? 2 red cards in the first 10 games, and we've lost our best defender for the next 3 games, which happen to be EFFING crucial!! very very frustrating, as Arteta would never have scored if Mbia had stayed on. the goal was miles, miles offside and I thought both linos had a very poor game.

Cesar - Absolute class. Some of the saves he pulled off were world class, even if he did have a shaky start.
Bosingwa - Good player, I'd like to see more urgency from him though, put in more tackles.
Nelsen - Solid for most of the game.
Mbia - Solid as a rock but absolutely nothing between the ears. Idiot.
Traore - Had a great game, linked up well with taarabt.
Granero - Played well in patches, went missing a few times.
Diakite - To be honest, I only remember seeing him in the second half.
Taarabt - Put himself about well, picked out some lovely passes.
SWP - ABSOLUTE GASH!! PLEASE get rid in January! PLEASE!! Can't pass, can't shoot, can't beat an egg, let alone beat a man.
Hoilett - Caused a few problems, had a goal disallowed but I didn't think he was offside.
Zamora - Didn't do much.

Cisse - Rubbish. Doesn't give a toss.
Onuoha - Did ok when he came on.
Mackie - Caused problems, should have scored.

[West Acton]

Agree

What baffled me at the end is we get a free kick and decided to play it short instead of putting it in the box and the ref blows up. Unprofessional!!!!!!!!!

[Gtleighsr3]

forgot
Mbia will be on a ban,god Hill back for so called easiest games.we are doomed.

[QPRDave]

We would have got at least a point today (and deservedly so) if Stephane Mbia hadn't been so bloody stupid. Sparky said all the indiscipline would be stamped out, where?? 2 red cards in the first 10 games, and we've lost our best defender for the next 3 games, which happen to be EFFING crucial!! very very frustrating, as Arteta would never have scored if Mbia had stayed on. the goal was miles, miles offside and I thought both linos had a very poor game.

Cesar - Absolute class. Some of the saves he pulled off were world class, even if he did have a shaky start.
Bosingwa - Good player, I'd like to see more urgency from him though, put in more tackles.
Nelsen - Solid for most of the game.
Mbia - Solid as a rock but absolutely nothing between the ears. Idiot.
Traore - Had a great game, linked up well with taarabt.
Granero - Played well in patches, went missing a few times.
Diakite - To be honest, I only remember seeing him in the second half.
Taarabt - Put himself about well, picked out some lovely passes.
SWP - ABSOLUTE GASH!! PLEASE get rid in January! PLEASE!! Can't pass, can't shoot, can't beat an egg, let alone beat a man.
Hoilett - Caused a few problems, had a goal disallowed but I didn't think he was offside.
Zamora - Didn't do much.

Cisse - Rubbish. Doesn't give a toss.
Onuoha - Did ok when he came on.
Mackie - Caused problems, should have scored.

Good analysis Ninja, and yes so frustrating when you look at the upcoming games, which makes me even angrier with him

[QPRDave]

forgot
Mbia will be on a ban,god Hill back for so called easiest games.we are doomed.

Clint will be ok if played at cb mate

[Shania]

We would have got at least a point today (and deservedly so) if Stephane Mbia hadn't been so bloody stupid. Sparky said all the indiscipline would be stamped out, where?? 2 red cards in the first 10 games, and we've lost our best defender for the next 3 games, which happen to be EFFING crucial!! very very frustrating, as Arteta would never have scored if Mbia had stayed on. the goal was miles, miles offside and I thought both linos had a very poor game.

Cesar - Absolute class. Some of the saves he pulled off were world class, even if he did have a shaky start.
Bosingwa - Good player, I'd like to see more urgency from him though, put in more tackles.
Nelsen - Solid for most of the game.
Mbia - Solid as a rock but absolutely nothing between the ears. Idiot.
Traore - Had a great game, linked up well with taarabt.
Granero - Played well in patches, went missing a few times.
Diakite - To be honest, I only remember seeing him in the second half.
Taarabt - Put himself about well, picked out some lovely passes.
SWP - ABSOLUTE GASH!! PLEASE get rid in January! PLEASE!! Can't pass, can't shoot, can't beat an egg, let alone beat a man.
Hoilett - Caused a few problems, had a goal disallowed but I didn't think he was offside.
Zamora - Didn't do much.

Cisse - Rubbish. Doesn't give a toss.
Onuoha - Did ok when he came on.
Mackie - Caused problems, should have scored.

But, why oh why, do we buy such players!!

[kron-1664]

Our squad seens to be a mish mash of strange players, we do not have solid team. Our forward and defensive departments are a joke and Hughes has to take the blame for this.

[silvercue]

Agree Ginger - especially about SWP. I wouldn't care if he retired tomorrow.

[cubicle]

Clint will be ok if played at cb mate

Clint is made for this type of situation. I reckon he'll come in and do a job. If people want some passion, he's the man and at CB i'm not worried.

[Ginger Ninja]

Unfortunately Ferdinand will probably get the nod over Hill.

[QPRDave]

Unfortunately Ferdinand will probably get the nod over Hill.

It would seem so with him on the bench every week