has warnocks tactical ineptitude cost us>????

[Factamondo]

lets face it other than some early season results he struggled big time on the tactical front....under sparky we seem much more organised!!!

[winalotto]

He was let down by the owners, but he was out of his depth imo

[bushcelt1]

tango and cash should have sold up earlier to give us a chance to have a proper pre-season but looking back at it warnock did'nt have the nous for this division and we should have picked up more points leading up to xmas. the players ill disipline did'nt help in important games also.

[Shania]

tango and cash should have sold up earlier to give us a chance to have a proper pre-season but looking back at it warnock did'nt have the nous for this division and we should have picked up more points leading up to xmas. the players ill disipline did'nt help in important games also.

Regarding that point, count parts of the management in as well.

[Terry-Mancini-123]

Will we ever get to hear the details of how he lost the dressing room. That would make a powerful book. Maybe we'll get it in 140 character bites over the next few seasons from our famous but corrently silent scribe....

[qpr]

Warnock messed up, hence why I was happy when he got the sack & Hughes came in because Hughes is a very good manager, as proven

[QPR1976]

Impossible to say with any certainty !

Tactics are built around the quality of your squad.
NW may not have brought in Cisse, Diakite, Taiwo, Onouha or Zamora.
But we may well have had Jelavic & Roberts, Bassong & Pienaar instead ?

Victories over Liverpool, Arsenal & Spurs may not have happened.
But we might have done better Away at West Brom, Sun'lan, Bolton, Blackburn, etc.

Who's to say we wouldn't have had more points than we currently do ?
I still think he was harshly treated, but long term I feel Hughes will be better for us (especially if we stay up).

In short - Dunno !

[californiahoop]

lets face it other than some early season results he struggled big time on the tactical front....under sparky we seem much more organised!!!

Yes, I felt he should have gone after the Chelsea game, against nine men and play one up front?

[QPRBENN]

Impossible to say with any certainty !

Tactics are built around the quality of your squad.
NW may not have brought in Cisse, Diakite, Taiwo, Onouha or Zamora.
But we may well have had Jelavic & Roberts, Bassong & Pienaar instead ?

Victories over Liverpool, Arsenal & Spurs may not have happened.
But we might have done better Away at West Brom, Sun'lan, Bolton, Blackburn, etc.

Who's to say we wouldn't have had more points than we currently do ?
I still think he was harshly treated, but long term I feel Hughes will be better for us (especially if we stay up).

In short - Dunno !

Agreed 100% - people seem to forget where we were when Neil took over

[californiahoop]

Agreed 100% - people seem to forget where we were when Neil took over

To counter that, he still had Hill, Adel, Mackie? Ferdinand & Buz who I don't believe he got the best out of this year, he would never have dropped SWP or Barton for the matter.

Hill has always been the best defender at the club and a way should have been found to incorporate him in the defense, I am not now saying this about the man but have been raving about him for two years!

I don't like slagging NW off because he pulled off a miracle getting us up but, he hasn't got the tactical skills for this level.

I wish him all the best in the future!

[Bigdave]

Warnock was hammpered when T&C didnt give him any dough for strengthening the squad pre-season. It was an up hill battle from then on. I disagree he was out of his depth. He has his faults but has to be remembered for the fantastic job he did getting us up.

[Kevster269]

He promised me (and 1000s of others) a response to our email and I'm still waiting. Until I get a handwritten apology I shall refuse to support him as I once did!

Did anybody ever get a response??

[californiahoop]

Warnock was hammpered when T&C didnt give him any dough for strengthening the squad pre-season. It was an up hill battle from then on. I disagree he was out of his depth. He has his faults but has to be remembered for the fantastic job he did getting us up.

He manages on emotion, in the top flight that only takes you so far.

He needs to get the right team around himself in-order to prosper in the top league.

I agree the that T&C did hamper him but a few tactical changes in a some of the games earlier in the season would have helped us pick up a few more points, I remember Hill screaming at the bench for them to change things as he was getting over run against Norwich.

[QPR's Number 10]

Forget the games under Neil Warnock this season, if we end up going down it is down to our away record since Hughes came. We have got a solitary point from our seven away games with him in charge. I'm afraid, that if that doesn't change in our next two away games, that will be the biggest factor that sends us down I've said it before, we would be mid table now if the owners hadn't made the stupid decision to replace our Manager midway through the season

[Factamondo]

Yes, I felt he should have gone after the Chelsea game, against nine men and play one up front?

well i for one was fuming by our second half performance when the s....hite shouldve drew and even won the game with nine men....i knew that day warnock was out of his depth in this league!!