whos been the best newcomer.............n worst

[DouDou_87]

Boothryod worst,
If he scores the winner tomorrow.....Cisse for best....

Cisse for best?? He's scored 3 goals since January and dropped us in it massively with his suspensions.

Best signing in Jan was Bobbie or Samba

Worst...so many to choose from... Puncheon, SWP, Barton, Bothroyd

[W12pHilOsOPher]

Perone worst
Young best

[superhoop67]

for me samba diakite the best by a country mile.........the most dissapointing also by a country mile..........swp

i remember you saying how good SD was after his debut

[vblockranger]

Best= Cisse
Worst= SWP..DJ..Bothroyd..Dyer..Puncheon..Perone..Shittu. . take your pick

[bushcelt1]

Best= Cisse
Worst= SWP..DJ..Bothroyd..Dyer..Puncheon..Perone..Shittu. . take your pick

throw barton into the worst and i'd agree-3/4 good games in a season from your captain is disgracful.

[vblockranger]

throw barton into the worst and i'd agree-3/4 good games in a season from your captain is disgracful.

probably right mate....add Barton to that.

[Norths]

Ferdinand Best
SWP Worst

Likes of Perone, Dyer etc have hardly featured so not even worth mentioning

[Bigdave]

SWP worst. Not even a contest really.

Worst buy this season. Worst buy, money wise we have made in my lifetime.

I have been truly shocked at just how poor he has looked.

Cant cross, cant beat a defender and cant shoot.

What the f0ck can he do??

Best buy this season? Diakite has improved and looks a player. Have been quite impressed with Traore as well at times.Have only seen Zamora have 1 decent game and that was against Arsenal when he was immense.

[kron-1664]

best - traore, diakite and cisse

worst - SWP , bothroyd

dyer and campbell have been injured all season so cant be judged on performances although they ,at no fault of their own, are a waste of money