Taarabt not good enough for PL

[rangertillidiedan]

If Zamora had scored from Adels pass yesterday I guarantee this thread wouldn't have been started. Everyone is entitled to an opinion but thinking someone should be sold who has played a massive part in our last 3 wins is ridiculous. Fickle

[paulmason]

One of the assists being just last Wednesday v Swansea for Buszacky, it's called vision, being able to spot 1 man in space amongst a crowd.

Did you knock one out ?

[qprbrisbanedivision]

A little bit clearer than watching matches from the other side off the world

Over the course off the season Taarabt has been one of our better performers especially at home and has played a major part in our last 3 wins.

Gd to see its our international fanbase giving Taarabt stick from watching games behind there PCs and off course Mason

Not at all mate...only watched 3 or 4 games on pc..most are live fox tel (sky) coveragre

Cant really agree with your second sentence but thats obviously your opinion, and no amount of stats, facts will change your mind, so fair enough

As for your final sentence, I said the same pre-season, as you may remember and was told how fantastic he would be..blah blah blah, I've waited, and waited and am still waiting for all these fans; who obviously know more than me because they go to th game; to show me the real tarrabt.
He truely is a gifted player, i agree, but as for being a great pem player, I'm sorry but there is jut no way anyone can defend that. There is a massive diffrence
The fact that the rest aint so great doesnt help Tarbs, but I'd have Cisse, Faurs, Diakite, JB and maybe even Hill ahead of him in our team-Personally
And for the record, Cisse has scored how many? in how many games?

I think Tarbs is a fantastic player, just aint made the step up to prem level yet...I wish he would but i fear he's run out of time?!

[W12_Ranger]

Not at all mate...only watched 3 or 4 games on pc..most are live fox tel (sky) coveragre

Cant really agree with your second sentence but thats obviously your opinion, and no amount of stats, facts will change your mind, so fair enough

As for your final sentence, I said the same pre-season, as you may remember and was told how fantastic he would be..blah blah blah, I've waited, and waited and am still waiting for all these fans; who obviously know more than me because they go to th game; to show me the real tarrabt.
He truely is a gifted player, i agree, but as for being a great pem player, I'm sorry but there is jut no way anyone can defend that. There is a massive diffrence
The fact that the rest aint so great doesnt help Tarbs, but I'd have Cisse, Faurs, Diakite, JB and maybe even Hill ahead of him in our team-Personally
And for the record, Cisse has scored how many? in how many games?

I think Tarbs is a fantastic player, just aint made the step up to prem level yet...I wish he would but i fear he's run out of time?!

PC / TV whats the difference

Being at the game and watching a game on a square electronic box you don't get to see all the positives of his performances

[qprbrisbanedivision]

If Zamora had scored from Adels pass yesterday I guarantee this thread wouldn't have been started. Everyone is entitled to an opinion but thinking someone should be sold who has played a massive part in our last 3 wins is ridiculous. Fickle

I was only watching from behind a screen, but didnt he get subbed yesterday? Are we saying he had a good game yesterday?

i obviously dont know because im not at the ground, stuggling to see over peoples heads with a sh**e view.

Why did MH take him of?, didnt seem injured. was he?

[qprbrisbanedivision]

]PC / TV whats the difference[/B]
Being at the game and watching a game on a square electronic box you don't get to see all the positives of his performances

About $100 a month....

so was i wrong in thinking he had a bad game yesterday then?
Personally thought he was very ordinary? Do you think he played well? i assume you were at the game...

would like to know you view of his performance...?

[rangertillidiedan]

I was only watching from behind a screen, but didnt he get subbed yesterday? Are we saying he had a good game yesterday?

i obviously dont know because im not at the ground, stuggling to see over peoples heads with a sh**e view.

Why did MH take him of?, didnt seem injured. was he?

Never said he had a good game. Didn't play well but still set up one of our best chances. All I'm saying is that asking for Adel to be sold is ridiculous

[qprbrisbanedivision]

Never said he had a good game. Didn't play well but still set up one of our best chances. All I'm saying is that asking for Adel to be sold is ridiculous

Fair enough mate, thats your opinion and i respect that. personally i dont agree with you but thats just me.

[rangertillidiedan]

Fair enough. You saying we should sell him then?

[BigDanShittu]

Taarabt is good enough for the prem definitely. However what does pish me off is when he is shoite, like yesterday, and people say he should not get subbed because he could do something. We needed to take him off earlier and add width we had so much space down the left. Traore should have gone on for Tarbs and Taiwo, who was our best player along with Barton and Hill, should never have come off.

[nuffieldranger]

Cant blame any one player let alone tarbs, against swansea and arsenal he was great ! what was the differance between them games ? in one word MOVEMENT ! we were almost static whilst on the ball.
Also when we look at the game in the cold light of day and the aid of MOTD ben foster made an amazing save and lots of other keepers would never have got there body in the way of bobbys shot the way he did thats my opinion

[TRING-RANGER]

I suppose in the same vein Bale/modric/defoe et al are not good enough for the PL as the webbed ones beat them at the lane ffs

Adels a loose cannon you never know whats going to turn up on the day which means neither do other players all you need is one spark of brilliance and bingo he is a moody f--r and we need to get behind him IMO

[californiahoop]

All Adel needs now is good tactical coaching, regular first team football and maybe stamina training and he will be fine.

The kid has it all, and the one thing you can't coach is skill, and he has it by the bucket load!

He was ignored at Spurs, probably due to his attitude, when he joined us, we didn't have the right backroom staff to improve his game, so he then spent the next two years doing the same things as before not developing as a footballer.

Now, with the right team behind him he will be a top player, I think we might regret it if we don't persevere with him.

The lad is as strong as an ox, allied with his skill I believe he could develop into a top striker/ forward. The one think a striker has to be willing to do repeatedly and have no fear of the outcome is shoot, and as we know, Adel doesn't need a second invitation.

We now have the infrastructure in place to bring the very best out of Adel, this guy could end up being a legend, he has all the attributes of a Rodney Marsh( just my opinion).

Lets hope we stay up, he has a good preseason, no is he, isn't he bull this summer, and I think he will truly announce his arrival next season!

[MattyRangers]

IMO, Adel is easily good enough for the PL, he has come on leaps and bounds htis year and is only going to get better under Sparkie. He has such much creativity ability its unreal, no way should we sell him.

[W12_Ranger]

About $100 a month....

so was i wrong in thinking he had a bad game yesterday then?
Personally thought he was very ordinary? Do you think he played well? i assume you were at the game...

would like to know you view of his performance...?

No mate i was at work, I'm not talking about his individual performance I'm talking about his overall contribution this season

No need to get shirty, point I'm making is you able to get a better opinion on players performances when at matches, you know it, I know!