Jamie Mackie once again....

[SammyKojoe]

Offers NOTHING!! For all those that say he should be playing can you tell me what i miss?? He is always non existant.

Did nothing again today. Barely touched the ball and is a waste of a place. You look at how much Tarbs/SWP/Barton and Faurlin get on the ball compared to Mackie. He is an impact sub at best.

Yes i applaud his effort/desire but you need some quality and that is where he falls short. Biggest shock of the day was Warnock finally saw this and took him off!

[Andy Sinton 11]

[MYU]

Neil loves him.

[qpr]

He would be in my 25 man squad come the end of January. I like him too.

[MattyRangers]

Been alot better player than SWP this season. Lets start a thread on him aswell?

[Mr Lofty]

Offers NOTHING!! For all those that say he should be playing can you tell me what i miss?? He is always non existant.

Did nothing again today. Barely touched the ball and is a waste of a place. You look at how much Tarbs/SWP/Barton and Faurlin get on the ball compared to Mackie. He is an impact sub at best.

Yes i applaud his effort/desire but you need some quality and that is where he falls short. Biggest shock of the day was Warnock finally saw this and took him off!

Er, because we do not have anyone else?

[silvercue]

Been alot better player than SWP this season. Lets start a thread on him aswell?

Good shout my waist-line defective friend.

SWP has been worse than useless. JM is just out of his depth.

[Bigears]

Lol, we cant score goals and he has 2 in three games, set up Young at Stoke which is a high percentage of actual goals we have scored since he came back.

Mackie to me is like Liverpools Kyut, not the most skillful but brings other things to your team that you need, like engery, commitment and enthusiam as well as goals.

Would be in my starting 11 all the time with the current squad and players

[MattyRangers]

Good shout my waist-line defective friend.

SWP has been worse than useless. JM is just out of his depth.

[Ginger Ninja]

Offers NOTHING!! For all those that say he should be playing can you tell me what i miss?? He is always non existant.

Did nothing again today. Barely touched the ball and is a waste of a place. You look at how much Tarbs/SWP/Barton and Faurlin get on the ball compared to Mackie. He is an impact sub at best.

Yes i applaud his effort/desire but you need some quality and that is where he falls short. Biggest shock of the day was Warnock finally saw this and took him off!

2 goals in 3. what has swp done? cost us the game today. and he's pony.

[MattyRangers]

2 goals in 3. what has swp done? cost us the game today. and he's pony.

Yet another case of being in the "scapegoat" club.

[Ginger Ninja]

Yet another case of being in the "scapegoat" club.

Indeed. Maybe its because he isn't a big name?

[QPRDave]

Been alot better player than SWP this season. Lets start a thread on him aswell?

[kingsleyloftus]

would rather mackie than swp end of. swp messed up again today hasnt done anything since arriving.

[kingsleyloftus]

plus mackie unlucky to be ruled offisde early on in second half.