swp or mackie...my opinion.

[Ginger Ninja]

In my opinion, taarabt has to be given a go tomorrow. However, I would still play barton and faurlin in the middle, and DJ and helguson up top, which means swp or mackie will have to be dropped.
Donning my tin hat now, because I would drop swp.
Mackie comes in for some stick but imo he does something swp hasn't all season, and that is trouble defenders by running at them and taking them on. Swp's first touch has been awful and he can't seem to beat defenders at the mo, not just against utd and Liverpool but against wba and Norwich. I understand he hasn't been constantly playing in his position on the right, but even on the wing I have to say mackie has performed better. What he lacks in ability he makes up for in fearlessness and work rate. I'll probably get a load of stick for this but here's my team for tomorrow.

Kenny

Young Connolly Gabbidon Traore

Mackie Barton Faurlin Taarabt

Campbell Helguson

Be gentle.

[suttonranger]

Don't disagree but I would like the SWP that played against the toon or villa was it? When he was running at people and looking really sharp. I think we should give Adel a go as looked interested when he came on Sunday.
3 points please Santa!!!

[Ginger Ninja]

Don't disagree but I would like the SWP that played against the toon or villa was it? When he was running at people and looking really sharp. I think we should give Adel a go as looked interested when he came on Sunday.
3 points please Santa!!!

I would like to see that swp too mate, but that was months ago now and maybe a stint on the bench would give him a kick up the jacksy.

[LoftusRoadLad]

I would like to see a 4-2-1-3 system.

_______Barton_______Faurlin________

______________Adel_______________

___SWP________HH________DJ______

To me SWP is better at collecting passes from Adel and has a football brain whilst Mackie has a lotta energy.

[QPR DEVON]

swp all day long. all mackie does is run, he consistently loses the ball, his crossing is poor, his touch is awful, and his tracking back against united was non existent.

[lymehoop]

Adel showed in the short time he was on deserves a start tomorrow, right attitude and was looking for the ball. Vital game and we need his inspiration to get the crowd going, come on you r's we need 3 pts.

[Filiranger]

Taarabt in a free role behind SWP Helguson and Mackie.

Cerny

Young. Gabiddon. Connolly. Traore

Barton. Faurlin

Taarabt

SWP. Helguson. Mackie

[swanleyhoop]

I would like to see a 4-2-1-3 system.

_______Barton_______Faurlin________

______________Adel_______________

___SWP________HH________DJ______

To me SWP is better at collecting passes from Adel and has a football brain whilst Mackie has a lotta energy.

If DJ is fully fit. If not, push Traore up and put Hill at LB -- Traore can track back to help out.

[Factamondo]

bring back tony sealey!

[robbomk]

SWP over Mackie all day long. I'd also like to see Adel start, we desparately need his creativity.

[rangerforevereastcote]

Got to say ginger , mackie has done well for a half and not more in any game apart from
Norwich had been anonymous every second half he's been involved in
I'd start swp and bring mackie on last half hr

[suttonranger]

bring back tony sealey!

Not a bad shout and I thought you were a loon!! Remember the stick TS got when he first arrived? Turned out ok in the end albeit for a season & helped get us up

[lymehoop]

Not a bad shout and I thought you were a loon!! Remember the stick TS got when he first arrived? Turned out ok in the end albeit for a season & helped get us up

remember standing in the paddock by the players tunnel, absolutely shocked at the dogs abuse he received at half-time

[vblockranger]

SWP or Mackie?

SWP all day long

[upperloftpaul]

Said after Sundays game, that I would drop SWP to the bench. His contribution has lessened every week!