Carroll on loan?

[Ric-Roc]

Agreed.

Or is that disagreed but agreed?

[Kevster269]

If you dont agree to agree to disagree, does that mean you agree....

[MattyRangers]

If you dont agree to agree to disagree, does that mean you agree....

Agreed

[stainrodisalegend]

Think people are focusing on the fee too much - yes it was way over the top but we wouldn't have to pay any of that. For £35m you should expect a young torres or drogba and he was never that, but if we can't land bent or johnson or whoever we are aiming for on a perm in jan, you cd do a lot, lot worse. Put it this way, anyone from about Villa downwards wd be hugely strengthened by adding him to their squad.

[SammyKojoe]

Thought it might have been Carol Vorderman to help Gianni with maths when it comes to transfer fees but since he is gone my theory is wrong.

[maverick69]

Hmmmmmm. Mr Barton having a word in his shell-like perhaps?

[Kimimar0]

People are so dumb to talk about how he wasnt that good in the championship, he was 20 years old at the time. His body type and playing style doesnt usually see its best until late 20s but apparently spurs scouts think he reached his peak at 20.

Last season he showed with Newcastle that he is one of the best strikers in the Prem in the air and he also has an absolute rocket of a left foot. The problem is his energy levels seem way too low and he needs to work in his overall fitness.

[MattyRangers]

People are so dumb to talk about how he wasnt that good in the championship, he was 20 years old at the time. His body type and playing style doesnt usually see its best until late 20s but apparently spurs scouts think he reached his peak at 20.

Last season he showed with Newcastle that he is one of the best strikers in the Prem in the air and he also has an absolute rocket of a left foot. The problem is his energy levels seem way too low and he needs to work in his overall fitness.

Nothing like accepting differing opinions eh

[EYR]

Left Newcastle too soon and now struggling to live up to the price tag.Bit concernced he always injured but if its a loan deal we can just fck him back off to Liverpool.

[QPRDave]

Gotta say wasn't that impressed with him when he was at the toon.
Scored a few if I remember in the champs but still just struck me as a big lump
who could out muscle defenders.

[maverick69]

#muggedorffff

http://www.the-playmaker.com/t8654-andy-carroll-set-to-go-on-loan-to-qpr-until-january

[Del]

People are so dumb to talk about how he wasnt that good in the championship, he was 20 years old at the time. His body type and playing style doesnt usually see its best until late 20s but apparently spurs scouts think he reached his peak at 20.

Last season he showed with Newcastle that he is one of the best strikers in the Prem in the air and he also has an absolute rocket of a left foot. The problem is his energy levels seem way too low and he needs to work in his overall fitness.

On your first point, so what if he was 20?? If as good as he's supposed to be then he'd have done better in the runaway team in the division. As for his body type and playing style... well it's big lump and put it about a bit (so to speak)... was then and is now.

[loftustoad]

a few weeks ago didn't Warnock come out saying Bothroyd is as good as Carroll?