marsh or bowles.........who's the greatest eve'r'!!!!

[Factamondo]

for me stanley bowles is the greatest player ever to wear our famous hooped shirts.........in todays market id actually see him being worth 25-30 million...more of a team player than marsh and for that reason he gets my vote!!!

[superhoop67]

years ago Bowles mentioned this ,and said how often did Marsh turn it on away from home .

[W12_Ranger]

for me stanley bowles is the greatest player ever to wear our famous hooped shirts.........in todays market id actually see him being worth 25-30 million....more of a team player than marsh and for that reason he gets my vote!!!

If Bowles was the sort of player many a R's fan says he was then would it be wrong to say £50 million+ be more appropriate....I mean Chelsea paid £24 million for SWP!

[Factamondo]

he swerved one way the oppo full back went the other way............poetry in motion imho........his euro campaign was stuff of boys own.........makes tarabbt look like a sunday league player!!

[knocker]

stan was best player but Rodney was most important player as it all really started for Qpr when he joined. will always be god to me.

[Connell10]

Didnt see marsh play so for stan really is the man! Asked my dad les who is 84 and he reckons marsh was the better , 2 footed and good in the air , unlike stan whos mostly left footed and not known for his heading powers! Still stan was the best player I ever saw in a rangers top!

[qprted]

this question

this question always asked of me
and i know what the answer must be................I love the stupidity of stanley
who excelled in his stupidity
but theres only one man who captivated us in history
and that was the legand of rod erney
he could pass the ball from foot to foot
a 40 yard pass on the shilling he could put
there could never be another hot rod
in football terms he was a god
i once saw him tear a team to shreds,they just couldnt defend
and there goalkeepeer was a mental wreck in the end
watch him pass the ball..............,boy it would bend
so thats just my point of you
its difficult to know if its true
but in my life ive been so impressed
by the stylish marsh,he was so smartley dressed
the problems started where stanley goes
if he got nervous he would pick his nose
he never had the panache of marsh,the bermondsy kid who likes to bath
so please dont compare these players again,STAN BETTER THAN ROD YOUR HAVING A LAUGH

[Nodge70]

Bowles.

Did it consistently at the top end of the highest level for year after year and excelled in our European run.

Marsh put our name on the map and won us our only trophy but missed most of our one year up in 68/69 and never really did the business for Man City either.

[loftlag]

Ssttaaanley

[Phil's R's]

Stan Bowles for me, never saw Rodney Marsh play live for the R's, but bowles was different class, without any doubt, The Greatest player ever to wear the famous blue & white hooped shirt.

[vblockranger]

never saw Marsh play but Stan was truly the man :-)

[Terry-Mancini-123]

No definitive answer to this, just depends on your temperament really.

For me, Rodney is the one. Nobody had ever heard of QPR before him, and the kids took to him and the excitement he generated was the key to the success that was to follow.

[Bigdave]

Before my time but have to be honest im not a great fan of Marsh the man. Stuck up his own ar5e.

Had a p1nt or 2 with Sir Stan, top fella.

[72bus]

my 1st game was a 0-1 defeat at home rodney played but i grew up sitting on top of the cafe in the loft and let me tell u stan was the man, no one will ever take that away from him and he had time for the fans.... i`d walk a million miles for one of your goals oh stanley

[LoftusRoadLad]

No brainer....wot all you young ones are saying is you have HEARD of Rodney but not seen him play live...same goes with Georgie Best ?....They were the players fans want to part with their cash to watch....Stan was a fantastic player for us but Rodney Marsh is the number one legend.