Your 25-man squad and starting eleven?

[Frode]

How will it look on friday? Think NW will gamble and only register 2 goalkeepers. No room for Vaagan Moen, Cerny, Hulse, Perone, Shittu + Cook, Rowlands, Borrowdale. Harriman, Andrade and Hewitt don't need to be registred. Would drop Agyemang for just about everyone mentioned above, but think NW will want him in the squad until january

1. Paddy KENNY
2. Bradley ORR
3. Clint HILL
4. Shaun DERRY
5. Fitz HALL
6. Danny GABBIDON
7. Adel TAARABT
8. Kieron DYER
9. Dj CAMPBELL
10. Jay BOTHROYD
11. Alejandro FAURLIN
12. Jamie MACKIE
13. Armand TRAORE
14. Akos BUZSAKY
15. Anton FERDINAND?
16. Matthew CONNOLLY
17. Joey BARTON
18. Luke YOUNG
19. Patrick AGYEMANG
20. Shaun WRIGHT-PHILLIPS?
21. Tommy SMITH
22. Heidar HELGUSON
25. Hogan EPHRAIM
26. Brian MURPHY
27. Jason PUNCHEON

Kenny

Young Ferdinand Gabbidon Traore

Derry Faurlin

Wright-Phillips Barton Taarabt

Bothroyd

Subs: Murphy, Connolly, Buzsaky, Puncheon, Smith, Helguson, Campbell

So when everyone is fit, no room for Mackie, Dyer, Hall even on the bench

We will survive, we are QPR

[W12hoops]

I don't think NW will put DJ on the bench. SWP probably no.29. Agree with you on the rest

[Rebel R's]

Agyemang should not make the 25,he is SHITE(league 1 standard at best),and Dyer when fit will make the squad

[QPR1234]

interesting.. perone misses out?

its going to be difficult but i reckon if puncheon signs u wont see ephraim in that list

[Frode]

Agyemang should not make the 25,he is SHITE(league 1 standard at best),and Dyer when fit will make the squad

No need to tell me, tell Neil! Agree about Dyer. Buzsaky in the stands then

[Slydo]

I think Dj will play up front in place of Bothroyd. But pretty solid. I also think putting Taarabt out on the left will happen.

just a quick question can Young play center back? Cos we still have Dyer when hes fit (So many 2 games a year lol) But seriously when he is fit Dyer can be a great player.

[Frode]

interesting.. both perone and dyer miss out?

its going to be difficult but i reckon if puncheon signs u wont see ephraim in that list

Have Dyer in the squad, but not Perone. We'll have Hall, Gabbidon, Ferdinand, Connolly, Orr and Hill in the squad who could all play in Perone's position. Maybe he should go out on loan like Ramage. Shittu should never been resigned

[paulmason]

NW has wanted Puncheon for a long time, so I can see him starting if he is fit enough.

Team v Newcastle
------------------- Kenny -------------------
- Young - Ferdinand - Gabbidon - Traore -
------------ Derry --- Barton ----------------
- Wright-Phillips --- Taarabt --- Puncheon -
------------------ Campbell ------------------


Toodle Pip
19. Patrick AGYEMANG
25. Hogan EPHRAIM

[Captain Planet]

Mackie won't make the cut IMO. He'll be loaned out till January.

Shittu and Perone will miss out. Maybe Hogan too.

[Frode]

NW has wanted Puncheon for a long time, so I can see him starting if he is fit enough.

Team v Newcastle
------------------- Kenny -------------------
- Young - Ferdinand - Gabbidon - Traore -
------------ Derry --- Barton ----------------
- Wright-Phillips --- Taarabt --- Puncheon -
------------------ Campbell ------------------


Toodle Pip
19. Patrick AGYEMANG
25. Hogan EPHRAIM

Don't think Puncheon will start ahead of Faurlin, Bothroyd and Smith. Think he is more of an impact sub with his pace. Your front 4 is too attack minded imho

[johnp]

For me the 25 are:

1. Paddy KENNY
2. Bradley ORR
3. Clint HILL
4. Shaun DERRY
5. Fitz HALL
6. Danny GABBIDON
7. Adel TAARABT
8. Kieron DYER
9. Dj CAMPBELL
10. Jay BOTHROYD
11. Alejandro FAURLIN
12. Jamie MACKIE
13. Armand TRAORE
14. Akos BUZSAKY
15. Anton FERDINAND?
16. Matthew CONNOLLY
17. Joey BARTON
18. Luke YOUNG
20. Shaun WRIGHT-PHILLIPS?
21. Tommy SMITH
22. Heidar HELGUSON
26. Brian MURPHY
27. Jason PUNCHEON
PERONE
CERNY

Think he will need 3 goalies. May possibly go for Ageymang rather than Mackie as Mackie is unlikely to be really fit until December. If Puncheon is only loan to January, Mackie could then replace him. Also, will probably need 4 strikers. Think he will keep Perone due to injury susceptibility of Hall, Gabbidon and Dyer.

Kenny

Young Ferdinand Gabbidon Traore

Derry Faurlin

Wright-Phillips Barton Taarabt

Bothroyd

Subs: Murphy, Connolly, Buzsaky, Puncheon, Smith, Helguson, Campbell

In away matches I would also have Hill on subs bench instead of Helguson

[James1979]

Barton's our best player, so he should play where Paul Mason has him. He needs to be involved all over the pitch. YOu can't stick him in the Adel role.

[Felt]

The rules are that you have to select three goalkeepers in the 25, according to the BBC at least.

[LoftusRoadLad]

Warno is gonna be in a difficult position. He has to make decisions on who to release from their contracts so they can join another club. Free agents can move during the closed season.

[paulmason]

Your front 4 is too attack minded imho

I do not understand what you are saying about being too attack minded.

SWP, is listed in his most effective position, on the right wing.
Puncheon, is in most effective position, on the right/left wing.
Taarabt is listed in his most effective position, behind the striker.
DJ Campbell in listed in his preferred position, in front of goal.

Please remember behind them they will have Derry and Barton.

What would you suggest ?