Jason Puncheon

[Nodge70]

But he was "bombed out" on loan to teams 1 and 2 divisions above him last year. Like I said - it's his attitude that is a bit of a problem when it comes to Southampton.

What about similar problems at Barnet? Not being picked up by any other club would also indicate that skill and technique are a bit of a problem at a higher level. Eric Cantona had attitude problems. Man Utd still took a chance.

Poor player. The very fact that we are even linked with him displays a startling lack of any ambition whatsoever.

You don't strengthen a team to play Premier League football by signing Jason Puncheon.

[maverick69]

FL show???? wtf now I know you are having a giraffe.

I mean they show all but 10 secs of each league 1 side.

*facepalm*

Well that combined with the local FL league shows is plenty to show a snapshot of his skills. And - if he is so carp the why was he loaned out to teams 1 and 2 leagues above him then?

[Ginger Ninja]

Not when his opinion is from watching 10 secs of the FL league show.

I just don't get why WR is all of a sudden sh it?

Expensive yes but a far better player than Puncheon and I think deep down you agree Ninja. I think you are questioning maybe my arrogants to question him but I don't think you are questioning my judgement

In my opinion, yes routledge is better than puncheon. But I'm not about to start digging a guy out because his opinion differs from mine. He didnt say the exact words Wayne routledge is sh it now did he?

[WeAreQPR12]

What about similar problems at Barnet? Not being picked up by any other club would also indicate that skill and technique are a bit of a problem at a higher level. Eric Cantona had attitude problems. Man Utd still took a chance.

Poor player. The very fact that we are even linked with him displays a startling lack of any ambition whatsoever.

You don't strengthen a team to play Premier League football by signing Jason Puncheon.

and I think we will leave it there and finish on that fact

[maverick69]

and I think we will leave it there and finish on that fact

Fact? That's not a fact - that's an opinion.

Then again - it looks I'll have to work hard on being a thick knuckle dragger to have an opinion round here judging by your responses.

[stanistheman]

Woo.........someone bombed out by Southampton in League 1. Woo.....

Well worth a £700 season ticket.

Not particularly inspiring, and certainly not worth the increased prices fans are paying, but at least he has scored in the Premiership, unlike Routledge.

[qpr]

This deal just rings out Jamie Mackie. Stop being negative and believe in Warnock

[geejaybee]

Nice cheap alternative for WR. I would of preferred the ex wycombe youngster.

Me too.Matt Phillips, over 6' fast,skilfull and currently kicking his heels up in Blackpool.

[loftustoad]

Working at Southampton club shop while at uni. Saw him play quite a few times at the beginning of last season. I would be very worried if we bought him. Very.

[vblockranger]

Puncheon, Dyer, Hulse, Agyemang, Pellicori, Alberti, Hogan, Webber = why im not bothering with over inflated tickets this season

[QPR1234]

there was only 3 standout players from blackpool

adam, vaughn and campbell. the rest are championship quality at best. not sure what exactly puncheon has done to merit a move to prem?

[Connell10]

He has the qualitys rangers look for in a player, he is cheap , he is cheap , oh hang he is cheap!

[loftlag]

Spot on nodge.

I am trying to work out where he gets all this info from regarding Jason being such a quality player. He must of spent plenty of time down blackpools training ground.

I actually thought WR crossing had improved and he was a massive improvement on mackie. Warnock got him playing well so lets not all pretend he was sh it now we won't be signing him.

Sorry I cant see this massive iimprovement on Mackie , more skillful yes but put together Mackies power work rate and never say die attitude makes them pritty level pegging imo ,also isnt Routs expsive at 1.5mil

[rockandroll]

[Minty85]

Sorry I cant see this massive iimprovement on Mackie , more skillful yes but put together Mackies power work rate and never say die attitude makes them pritty level pegging imo ,also isnt Routs expsive at 1.5mil

Plus Mackie was playing out of position. An out and out winger should be much better than a striker playing in that wide role, but as you said there wasn't a lot in it.