Graham or DJ Campbell?

[James1979]

Hypothetical because we won't sign Graham and Campbell is a rumour, but who would people rather?
For me it's got to be Campbell.....proven in the premiership....and cheaper.

[qblockpete]

Dj Campbell has done well in the premiership.

I remember everyone was so gutted that Ched Evans never signed and looked what happened to him.

I rate Graham but you are taking a big risk taking a championship striker up to the premiership. One good season is not always followed by another good one

[PeterG]

I would take Graham over Cambell admittedly its a bit of a risk but DJ needs too many chances to score, I think Graham will do better and there is improvement to come from him I dont think Cambell has any more improvement in him

Either way we need a better striker than either of them to also come in if we are going to stay up.

[W4 R]

Last night a DJ saved my life...........

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aDS9CF38ur4

[kron-1664]

DJ Campbell has proved he can cut it in the Prem, Graham hasnt yet so on that basis would rather have Campbell.

[Insider]

Campbell it is then your wish is my command

[stainrod10]

Graham

[KASPARS BOOTS]

Wanted Graham gutted we missed out on him, think he will flourish in the coming years, seems to have all the necessary attributes.
Would be happy to get DJ Campbell.

[singingranger]

sheron

[paulmason]

Graham all day long and on the basis that West Ham have offered Blackpool £1.25M for him, we will end up with neither, but dont panic, we have Heider, Hulse, Hewitt and Pat.

West Ham have also offered Newcastle £3M for Nolan which is a bargain in my books and its hilarious that they have a better budget than we do for players.

[stainrod10]

who's Sharon?

[paulmason]

DJ Campbell has proved he can cut it in the Prem, Graham hasnt yet so on that basis would rather have Campbell.

Working on that basis, you would swap Taarabt for someone with PL experience ?

[Gkiss100]

I would of rather Graham , would of suited our system and is a natural finisher . But for the price Campbell would be a great signing .

[BennyBoyRs]

Graham, without a doubt.

[stainrod10]

Suppose Swans really wanted DJ but settled for Graham!