Newcastle winger Routledge set for £1.5m switch to QPR

[Del]

Great news. He could do fine in the prem for us. People say he's never cut it but has he ever had a run of games in the prem? He would get that with us and could thrive after a couple of good displays.... he's quick, skillfull, works hard and can deliver a final ball or finish.

Those are the right ingredients for a winger.

[kingsleyloftus]

WR has done superb since the move.

However, he always does do well when playing for a contract.

He is a mercenary of the highest order no loyalty and I'm sure his form will dip once he has signed permanently. Give it 8-10 months we will be saying how poor / disinterested he looks before he is off for another loan move looking for a signing on fee elsewhere.

Saying that thanks for some great displays and match winning goals

[Morris]

WR has done superb since the move.

However, he always does do well when playing for a contract.

He is a mercenary of the highest order no loyalty and I'm sure his form will dip once he has signed permanently. Give it 8-10 months we will be saying how poor / disinterested he looks before he is off for another loan move looking for a signing on fee elsewhere.

Saying that thanks for some great displays and match winning goals

Bit harsh Kingsley??

[kingsleyloftus]

Don't get me wrong he has been great so far, but I'm not Kean on WR personality.

In my opinion you have to wonder why he jumps ship at any given opportunity and at such a young age he's never with a club for that long. Maybe his agent? I don't know but Im hopeful NW can keep him playing consistently at this level and above. And that he proves me wrong.

[Morris]

Don't get me wrong he has been great so far, but I'm not Kean on WR personality.

In my opinion you have to wonder why he jumps ship at any given opportunity and at such a young age he's never with a club for that long. Maybe his agent? I don't know but Im hopeful NW can keep him playing consistently at this level and above. And that he proves me wrong.

He's had a lot of clubs, no doubt about that.