Tweet
I was reading with interest the thread below regarding Helguson, Taarabt and a comparison to Hulse. I then got thinking about all of our signings. If you had to score them 1-5 on the scores below what would you give them and overall what is your average score, which then gets allocated to Sir Neil?
5 - Excellent
4- Good
3- Average
2 - Poor
1 - What was he thinking?
Paddy Kenny - 5 for me without a doubt, best keeper in this division
Clint Hill - 5 for me, though I found myself choosing between 4 and 5
Kyle Walker - 5 - Class
Danny Shittu - 4 at least, timely and just as we remembered. Not washed up and past it as lots said when others, like me, called for his return
Bradley Orr - 3 for me. Not quick enough, distribution average, heading quite good and doesn't give in
Pascal Chimbonda - 3 - Seems capable but not seen enough yet
Shaun Derry - 5 - Without Derry we wouldn't be top
Tommy Smith - 4 - Without injuries and a real run in the team he may have made 5. Not as good as I remember when he was with Watford but a good purchase
Jamie Mackie - 4 - Started really well but then did fade a bit for me before his terrible injury in January.
Wayne Routledge - 5 - He has been superb and is a real threat
Petter Vaagan Moen - 3 - Not seen enough yet but seems capable
Adel Taarabt - 5
Rob Hulse - 2 - Poor rather than "what were you thinking" as I would have bought him too and was excited like most at his signing
Leon Clarke - 1 - even Warnock admitted it was a risk when he bought him
Ishmael Miller - 4 - Seems to be a decent player,more to come I hope
Average score - 3.87. Closer to good than average and proved in the league position. Top marks Neil,take out Clarke whom he knew wouldn't work and the average is 4.14.
What's your average?
5 - Excellent
4- Good
3- Average
2 - Poor
1 - What was he thinking?
Paddy Kenny - 5 for me without a doubt, best keeper in this division
Clint Hill - 5 for me, though I found myself choosing between 4 and 5
Kyle Walker - 5 - Class
Danny Shittu - 4 at least, timely and just as we remembered. Not washed up and past it as lots said when others, like me, called for his return
Bradley Orr - 3 for me. Not quick enough, distribution average, heading quite good and doesn't give in
Pascal Chimbonda - 3 - Seems capable but not seen enough yet
Shaun Derry - 5 - Without Derry we wouldn't be top
Tommy Smith - 4 - Without injuries and a real run in the team he may have made 5. Not as good as I remember when he was with Watford but a good purchase
Jamie Mackie - 4 - Started really well but then did fade a bit for me before his terrible injury in January.
Wayne Routledge - 5 - He has been superb and is a real threat
Petter Vaagan Moen - 3 - Not seen enough yet but seems capable
Adel Taarabt - 5
Rob Hulse - 2 - Poor rather than "what were you thinking" as I would have bought him too and was excited like most at his signing
Leon Clarke - 1 - even Warnock admitted it was a risk when he bought him
Ishmael Miller - 4 - Seems to be a decent player,more to come I hope
Average score - 3.87. Closer to good than average and proved in the league position. Top marks Neil,take out Clarke whom he knew wouldn't work and the average is 4.14.
What's your average?
post did actually make me feel upbeat on an very average monday morning!!
NPower Champions 2010/2011
Comment