Of the current squad...

[qprfc1989]

and regardless of whether they're out on loan or not, who is, in your opinion, the most overrated and underrated player we have??

Got the potential to divide a lot of opinion this thread!

Overrated - Tough, but I think for me Faurlin is - on his day he's terrific, no doubt about it, but I can count on one hand the number of "days" he's had this season. Inconsistent, but I'd probably still play him over Rowlands, not sure about over a fully fit Buzsaky though...

Underrated - It's between:

- Tommy Smith (who many on here think is who we should overlook to accommodate either PVM or Routledge in the side)

- Rob Hulse (who some think is ######## because he hasn't put away some easy chances) - it's clear to me he's a good player though because he gets himself in the right positions and puts himself about, all that's missing is the goals and I'm certain they'll come - he's done it everywhere else!

- Patrick Agyemang - maybe he only performs when he sees me in the crowd, but he was in my opinion our man of the match at Derby (super sub!!), gave Norwich defence problems and generally is a great player to have on the pitch in the last 20 mins of a game (not a 90min player I agree). I was certainly crying out for him away at Forest with 20 mins ago amongst a group of about 100 others!

[Ric-Roc]

Over rated-Hogan, some posters on here think he's Aaron Lennon & he's more Aaron Lemon

Under rated- Tommy Smith, industrious, hard working, sensible player.

[qprjim]

Good question

Over rated - Mackie, dont get me wrong a very decent squad player but some fans lauding of him was way over the top

Under rated - Helguson, for a small man he loses very few aerial battles and brings others in to play with ease. Smith would also be in with a shout.

[vblockranger]

over rated - Mackie for me too.

under rated - Smith (give him a chance in the centre!)

[Gerryhatrick]

Under-rated: Matt Connelly. Very rarely beaten in the air, and he has improved his game reading and positional sense this season. Works well with Gorksy, the understanding between them is solid, only dowside is lack of pace.

Over-rated: Adel (hides behind sofa). He is a match winner, sometimes, but we all remember him for 5 or 10 mins of magic every game. As a team player he is poor, too late to pass the ball even if he does choose to, often loses possesion when we have players committed forward, just a very frustrating player especially if he gets a bit moody. Doesn't track back and help defend, crowds our wide forwards, prevents us having 2 strikers. Don't get me wrong, he is probably our best player, just not as good as some people think, yet.

[Bigdave]

In my opinion.

Over-rated: Gorrks. Is sturdy enough but gets turned too easy and of course lacks pace to make up for it.

Under-rated: Rowlands. I still think he could do a job for us, but i think im in the minority here.

[Ginger Ninja]

Overrated...taarabt. for exactly the reasons gerry described above. Plus the fact his set pieces are dogshi.te.

Undefeated...Hulse. the only thing he has to work on is his finishing. The rest of his game (work rate, hold up play) is very good imo. Very easy to forget these things if he misses a few easy chances.

[QPR1234]

overrated - connolly. not as good as people say on here... IMO

underrated - hulse - gets so much stick for just 10 appearances. does alot of work for the team. sadly goals arent flowing.

[G.T.P]

under rated = mackie

over rated = routledge

[Ric-Roc]

over rated = routledge

[Bluehoop]

Under = Helguson, great in the air for his size and works his socks off.
Over = Ephraim, who sadly has never delivered on his potential, despite a good run in the team earlier this season

[qpr]

Underrated - It's between:

- Tommy Smith (who many on here think is who we should overlook to accommodate either PVM or Routledge in the side)

- Rob Hulse (who some think is ######## because he hasn't put away some easy chances) - it's clear to me he's a good player though because he gets himself in the right positions and puts himself about, all that's missing is the goals and I'm certain they'll come - he's done it everywhere else!

- Patrick Agyemang - maybe he only performs when he sees me in the crowd, but he was in my opinion our man of the match at Derby (super sub!!), gave Norwich defence problems and generally is a great player to have on the pitch in the last 20 mins of a game (not a 90min player I agree). I was certainly crying out for him away at Forest with 20 mins ago amongst a group of about 100 others!

Could not agree any more

[Gerryhatrick]

Crikey, this thread had the massive potential for posters slagging off each others choices and it surprisingly hasn't happened............ yet

Good to see us all respecting each others opinion, even if we disagree.

But hang on, here comes.........