I would take Phillips over Miller and McCarthy anyday? why wont NW?

[rickqpr]

Who would you rather want out of the 3?

Hands up if it was the miller we was talking about a couple of seasons ago then yes miller but as WBA site says not played at full 90 in 18 months he certainley is not the man he once was

[vblockranger]

Cos we only do benchwarming injury prone players that need a few run outs before they are fit (or break down again)....we're Queens Park Rangers...

[Sprocket]

Like it or not Miller is a direct replacement for Ageymang and is also suited to playing the lone striker role. Phillips plays off a front man which would mean Warnock changing the system. Would not say no to Phillips though

[californiahoop]

Who would you rather want out of the 3?

Hands up if it was the miller we was talking about a couple of seasons ago then yes miller but as WBA site says not played at full 90 in 18 months he certainley is not the man he once was

I know you shouldn't look back and compare but this situation reminds me of the Furlong signing, he suffered bad injury problems for a few years prior to joining us but when we got him fit we ended up with a gem!

IF, and I know it's a big IF but never the less, IF we can get this lad fit we have a beast of a centerforward on our hands!

I think with the addition of Routledge goals will not be as big a problem as some think, remember we are one of the highest scoring team in the championship without an out and out goal scorer, I think Miller will turn out to be the nuts of a signing!

[RangerJim]

[QUOTE=californiahoop;516515]

IF, and I know it's a big IF but never the less, IF we can get this lad fit we have a beast of a centerforward on our hands!
QUOTE]

Agree

Not signed yet tho!

[Gerryhatrick]

Philips is 38, I say again 38 !!! McCarthy is 33 or 34, but Miller is only 23, and even tho injured for 2 years, is probably young enough for his injury to properly heal, and maybe still has some improvement and something to prove. He is still really in the early stages of a footballing career, so should be hungry for success. If he passes a fitness test he got to be the better option. The other 2 must have peaked and now are on the slide, and we remember them for how good they used to be, not how good they could be in the future.