My view on todays game.

[WeAreQPR12]

Ok what a great result and I was delighted with the performance.

Walker is just superb and I think because I rate him so highly, I have probably been over critical on Clinton Hill who is fairly solid although we would need better in the premier.

Sign walker as he was fantastic, we really need him for the rest of the season. He is a RB and RW all in one and really is the star man.

I though Tarbs had a decent game and passed the ball really well. He is a decent passer of a ball so it was nice 2see him give it.

Tommy Smith had a great game and I don't feel he gets the credit he deserves. *this will upset Benny* but Mackie was extremely poor today. For all the work rate etc he did bugger all. Headless chicken is starting to make sense. If Moen comes in and does the business I would definately replace mackie.

Anyway I am sure Benny will have something to say but Mackie is definately overrated IMO.

[BennyBoyRs]

Oh dear, it's always nice to be on another posters mind all the time. I'm glad I e left an impression.

You're wrong by the way.

[EYR]

Ill be more than happy if Warnock signs another 9 goal headless chicken in january for 100k

[WeAreQPR12]

EYR did he do anything today? Apart from get outmuscled?

Mackie was very poor today and if you can highlight some good that he offered the team can u please remind me? Benny only used your name as I knew it would touch a nerve, and I am right by the way.

[DelTrotter]

Did you go today weare?

[superhoop67]

Ok what a great result and I was delighted with the performance.

Walker is just superb and I think because I rate him so highly, I have probably been over critical on Clinton Hill who is fairly solid although we would need better in the premier.

Sign walker as he was fantastic, we really need him for the rest of the season. He is a RB and RW all in one and really is the star man.

I though Tarbs had a decent game and passed the ball really well. He is a decent passer of a ball so it was nice 2see him give it.

Tommy Smith had a great game and I don't feel he gets the credit he deserves. *this will upset Benny* but Mackie was extremely poor today. For all the work rate etc he did bugger all. Headless chicken is starting to make sense. If Moen comes in and does the business I would definately replace mackie.

Anyway I am sure Benny will have something to say but Mackie is definately overrated IMO.

This team are 7pts clear and lost 2 all season , so not doing too bad , even with headless chickens and donkeys in the side

[Hertford Hoop]

I thought Mackie did well, he ran his socks off again. He hasn't scored too many since early doors but he never gives up. His running often makes spaces for others to fill and thats what he offers imo.

A good team effort today

[Quaz]

EYR did he do anything today? Apart from get outmuscled?

Mackie was very poor today and if you can highlight some good that he offered the team can u please remind me? Benny only used your name as I knew it would touch a nerve, and I am right by the way.

don't think you are, one bad game compared to how many good

[WeAreQPR12]

Delighted to be an R's fan and I don't want this to turn nasty, I just think Tommy smith doesn't get the credit he deserves, IMO he is a very crucial player and proven at this level. Mackie did have a purple patch when he scored those goals. I do wish him the best like any r's player but I don't actually rate him. Thought he was very poor today.

[SirLes]

Oh dear. Another excellent win, 7 points clear and still some posters try to pick holes and cant help being negative.

Its a team game. Mackie works harder than any player and is a hugely important part of a (so far) hugely successful season.

[Quaz]

Oh dear. Another excellent win, 7 points clear and still some posters try to pick holes and cant help being negative.

Its a team game. Mackie works harder than any player and is a hugely important part of a (so far) hugely successful season.

[WeAreQPR12]

Sir Les I don't want this to turn into an argument, I am just giving an opinion on mackie. I agree I should of put it differently.

He does work hard and did plenty of running today.

You do get alot of player that give 110% in lower leagues.

I also realise its a team game but I just thought he had a very poor game today. I am not moaning at the team as I thought we did great.

[bushcelt1]

Nice one quaz-hope you had a good one.....thought mackie played well but kenny was super in the first half-adel ran the show in the second. What a season to hand back your ticket!!!!

[WeAreQPR12]

Bush I see I have upset you too.

Fair play mate but I am just giving my opinion on mackie.

I think he is overrated by most of our fans so I guess I am on my own on this one but I can only judge him on what he offers. Yes work rate was excellent but did have a very poor game. I still think Moen if he does well, could and should push mackie for a starting place but I know he's loved by this board.

[Quaz]

Nice one quaz-hope you had a good one.....thought mackie played well but kenny was super in the first half-adel ran the show in the second. What a season to hand back your ticket!!!!

hope yours was as good as mine mate