would you swap mackie for routledge?

[NorwegianRanger]

Of course not!!!!

[acricketer]

No

[Bigears]

Look at what we had last year, loads of creativity (Tarb's, Routledge) but no spine. When things are going well we thrash teams, but when they dont and we got kicked over the park and stuggled. If Routledge goes to W"£$$% then they are in danger of failing as they will have no spine or guts.

Going back to the question, for me to get promoted you flair, passion, guts, commitment and team work. Not all players will have all the attributes but I think in our "squad" we have a reasonable balance, and swapping Routledge for Mackie will over balance the flair pot (Adel and Routledge will fight for the ball), and under balance the team work, commitment and passion pots.

Therefore to me keeping "Mackie" is as important as keeping Adel

[W6hoops]

That is a tough one. I think Mackies all round game would be the winner.

[qpr]

No way