If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Tough breaking into a side at the age of 19 isn't it ?
Of course it is mate, and I appreciate that we don't get to see who's doing what in training. But what I do know is that in terms of confidence/morale, the worst thing you can do to a young player is to drop him out of the picture just as he's starting to make progress. This is just what I feel happened to Oteh, as well as Shodipo before him. Also Wheeler, although he's hardly a young player.
Maybe we have too many players? Maybe Holloway is trying too hard to allow too many players a chance to make an impression. But I do feel that players just seem to disappear out of the picture for months on end, and then get brought in from the cold without any real explanation out of the blue. Ollie has always been a bit like that to be fair.
Compare him to someone like Warnock. In that promotion season you could pretty much predict Warnock's likely team selection before every game and be 90% right. He knew his best 11, and he used them as much as possible. Of course there was enough rotation to ensure that no players got burnt out, but there was definitely continuity. And there was never drastic changes in formation and playing personnel in League matches.
Doing well in this league isn't rocket science. Plenty of bang average teams will get themselves into the promotion picture every season just by playing to their strengths and getting the simple decisions right 9 times out of 10 (look at Preston and Millwall this season). I'd just like to see us get back to that personally.
How many youth team players did Warnock use in that season ? Didn't really have any to use did he, hence inexperience at this level was never a factor in team selection.
Warnock got the formula right that season (the Derry/Faurlin and Gorkks/Connolly partnerships plus the best midfielder in the league who was allowed to do what he wanted) but do you not think he would have changed it around if we weren't unbeaten for so long ?
Personally I think it's more of a case that Warnock plays the percentages game. He knows his trade and this league very well, he plays it reasonably safe and gets the basics right most of the time.
Holloway is the other end of the spectrum. He's just constantly rolling the dice, chancing his arm with madcap plans and crazy ideas. There is absolutely nothing about the guy that says "stability" for me. From his tactics & team selections, to his press conferences, even to some of the whacky clobber that he wears on a match day. Probably a great guy to have a beer with, but I'd hate to work for him. I don't think instability is ever a good trait for somebody in a managerial job.
Of course it is mate, and I appreciate that we don't get to see who's doing what in training. But what I do know is that in terms of confidence/morale, the worst thing you can do to a young player is to drop him out of the picture just as he's starting to make progress. This is just what I feel happened to Oteh, as well as Shodipo before him.
Not if you have one of the best youth development coaches in the country at the club. They will all know what it takes to get in that first XI and personally I'm glad it isn't so easy as it means we'll get real quality in that side.
Personally I think it's more of a case that Warnock plays the percentages game. He knows his trade and this league very well, he plays it reasonably safe and gets the basics right most of the time.
Holloway is the other end of the spectrum. He's just constantly rolling the dice, chancing his arm with madcap plans and crazy ideas. There is absolutely nothing about the guy that says "stability" for me. From his tactics & team selections, to his press conferences, even to some of the whacky clobber that he wears on a match day. Probably a great guy to have a beer with, but I'd hate to work for him. I don't think instability is ever a good trait for somebody in a managerial job.
Can't disagree on the huge gulf in difference between those two !
Comment