Proven respected manager, or keep gianni?

[terry ball]

Ian holloway says hardly anyone will touch our club with the current set up.
As I posted the other day, I have nothing against gianni, just his position at the club.

So, if we interviewed a host of higher caliber managers( ie curbs, coppell, Mancini, gullitt or whoever you fancy personally) and they said that they will be willing to take the job as long as they have full control and are responsible for all decisions football wise, do we get rid of the sporting director and give it a chance, or do we say "poke it, gianni stays no matter what"?

Thoughts please

[IsleworthRanger]

Holloway is just bitter and twisted

[eghamR]

Not only Holloway ...a few others have said the same according to a poster on here the other day ...I'm telling you we will end up with a manager who's just as desperate as we are!

[SirLes]

its going to be Fergie Jnr

[eghamR]

its going to be Fergie Jnr

Surely his old man will talk him out of it!

[QPRbob]

For us to forge ahead up the league and promotion we need a manager who has total control. The names being touted about would never work under the present regime. If it means that Giani has to relinquish his roll as Sporting Director, then so be it, he has to step down. That said I would like him to stay at our club, but have nothing to do with footballing matters.

[scarface]

No brainer this current set up hasnt worked for the last few years if a top manager wanted the job and said paladini had to go in order for him to the job then it's bye bye gianni..

[EYR]

Its obvious Paladini must have a job for life,hes going knowhere.

[eghamR]

Surely we could move him sideways ...chef in the canteen or something like that?

[paulmason]

For all those who want GP to stay, are Tottenham Hotspur a better football club, without their Director of Football Damien Comolli.

Its a no brainier for me, thanks GP for all you have done, but its time to go.

[vblockranger]

it will never work with him at the club. He seems to think this is HIS club and he will do as he pleases with it. If anyone ever upsets him at the club chances are they wont be around too much longer (Sousa for example) . Its a shame because i do believe he genuinely cares about Qpr but he just cant see that he is hindering us more than helping.

[Captain Clunge]

Like turkey's voting for Xmas putting this sort of thread up.

The gravy train passengers would never sack the driver.

[pkloft]

For all those who want GP to stay, are Tottenham Hotspur a better football club, without their Director of Football Damien Comolli.

Its a no brainier for me, thanks GP for all you have done, but its time to go.

couldn't agree more, put aside all the lovers or haters of the man i think it's obvious to most that he is punching above his weight of course he has brought in some great players to the club but he has also brought in some absolute stinkers, early on in his career with us i was very sceptical, not no more think he has his pluses & minuses but if we are to move forward as a club it must be "grazie Gianni ma arrivederci" maybe make him club president or something

we need a top class manager who will get players in who he wants & manage

[terry ball]

Like turkey's voting for Xmas putting this sort of thread up.

The gravy train passengers would never sack the driver.

That's a great way of putting it! Everyone seems to agree so far....
Lets see if the bisto boys are singing from the same hymn sheet

[paulmason]

They wont join in because they cant argue that Tottenham is not a better club since the retired the Director of football position.