Which defender would we start on if Ned went?

[corbray]

Ned's been a scapegoat for way too long, there'll be a honeymoon period for those that dislike him where they praise everything for maybe a week or two regarding our defence, then Bidwell or Perch, because there is too much love for Hall and Lynch.

Perch is a good shout for next target too, i'll flip a coin later to decide between perch and bidwell.

In all seriousness, ned isn't a scapegoat, hes just plain crap most of the time for us. Sure he has the odd game every now and then but most of the time he loses concentration or panics and fails to organise the defence properly which as a player whos 30 years old and with what ... 300+ or so games under his belt with most of those being premier league games he should easily be able to do

[maidstone_hoop]

In all fairness the two weak links consistently in our defence are Ned and Perch and they get called out on it because their performances are scary at times!

Both give the call away far to much and when they have both been moved on I'll be happy!

Lynch has the odd mistake in him but in general I think him and hall should be our choice partnership going forward!

[West Acton]

Hall has been pants this season but appears no one is prepared to acknowledge it

I thought CB would be our strength but between the four of them they have been woeful

[WeAreQPR12]

Hall has been pants this season but appears no one is prepared to acknowledge it

I thought CB would be our strength but between the four of them they have been woeful

The point is both Ned and hall need to be played alongside an organizer. I hate Ned, but he was v good when played alongside dunne. I have played centre half and you need to think of it as a relationship. Some pairings just don't work. We need to do everything we can to help halls progression as he is still just a young lad and playing alongside Ned is not helping

[West Acton]

Agree WeAre

[nanocopic]

If we lost Ned and Caulker will leave too I.imagine in the next 6 months at latest, then we need a new CB.

[Brian Wilson]

I've started on Perch already ...far worse than Ned. Though strangely not that bad when played on the left.