Smithies medical

[Bill]

apparently smithes having medical now. gutted, another bad move by the club. offering more money for second choice than the first choice bentley.

Don't rate Smithes

[MYU]

Does our club even know what a medical is, we send out a player on loan with a fee not knowing if his fit or not?

I find that embarrassing, should never have sent him out known that he wasn't fit and injured.

This goalkeeper seems to be on a never ending medical.

[CroydonCaptainJack]

Does our club even know what a medical is, we send out a player on loan with a fee not knowing if his fit or not?

I find that embarrassing, should never have sent him out known that he wasn't fit and injured.

This goalkeeper seems to be on a never ending medical.

I'm pretty sure we would have known he was injured but Sunderland decided they wanted someone who could play straight away. Why is that qprs fault?

[QPR1976]

Exactly, rather pay both keepers 20k each than 40k to one.

Makes you wonder. If Green does leave, that would be the 3rd keeper to leave this Summer.
Technically, we'd need to bring 2 keepers in to go with Lumley.

Both Bentley & Smithies ? Nah, surely not......That would be nuts.

[Is Dom Is Good]

With all this talk about replacing Green with Smithies or Bentley it got me thinking about how good they are because tbh i've never watched either of them play.

Green last time out in the Championship in 2013/4 had an average rating of 6.84 and averaged 27.4 passes per game at 55.9%. He also average 2.7 saves a game, .01 from inside the .1 yard box, 1.3 from inside the penalty area and 1.2 from outside the box.

In season 2014/15 Smithies played 44 games for an average rating of 6.50. He averaged 25.5 passes a game at a success rate of 37%. Per game he also averaged 3 saves, .2 from inside the 6 yard box, 1.6 from the penalty area and 1.2 form outside the box.

Bentley is harder to analysis due to him playing in the 4th tier last season however 21 clean sheets in 42 games is no mean feet and at the age of 22 seems to be a much more promising prospect that Smithies.

I still don't understand how we let McCarthy go. In his last season at Reading in the Championship he had an average rating of 7.00, averaged 28.2 passes at 45.6% success rate whilst making 3.9 saves a game whilst also only shipping 56 goals.

To sum it all up the board by discarding McCarthy has stuffed up, by potentially keeping Green especially on his wages has stuffed up, by looking to buy Smithies has stuffed up and by effectively giving up on Bentley has stuffed up. Hence I have come to the conclusion that they stuffed up.

[CroydonCaptainJack]

With all this talk about replacing Green with Smithies or Bentley it got me thinking about how good they are because tbh i've never watched either of them play.

Green last time out in the Championship in 2013/4 had an average rating of 6.84 and averaged 27.4 passes per game at 55.9%. He also average 2.7 saves a game, .01 from inside the .1 yard box, 1.3 from inside the penalty area and 1.2 from outside the box.

In season 2014/15 Smithies played 44 games for an average rating of 6.50. He averaged 25.5 passes a game at a success rate of 37%. Per game he also averaged 3 saves, .2 from inside the 6 yard box, 1.6 from the penalty area and 1.2 form outside the box.

Bentley is harder to analysis due to him playing in the 4th tier last season however 21 clean sheets in 42 games is no mean feet and at the age of 22 seems to be a much more promising prospect that Smithies.

I still don't understand how we let McCarthy go. In his last season at Reading in the Championship he had an average rating of 7.00, averaged 28.2 passes at 45.6% success rate whilst making 3.9 saves a game whilst also only shipping 56 goals.

To sum it all up the board by discarding McCarthy has stuffed up, by potentially keeping Green especially on his wages has stuffed up, by looking to buy Smithies has stuffed up and by effectively giving up on Bentley has stuffed up. Hence I have come to the conclusion that they stuffed up.

There was a relegation release clause.

[Jogo]

Does our club even know what a medical is, we send out a player on loan with a fee not knowing if his fit or not?

I find that embarrassing, should never have sent him out known that he wasn't fit and injured.

This goalkeeper seems to be on a never ending medical.

I heard we carry out our medicals in Lourdes.

[Is Dom Is Good]

There was a relegation release clause.

then the board stuffed up by offering him a contract with a relegation release cuase

[CroydonCaptainJack]

then the board stuffed up by offering him a contract with a relegation release cuase

That was probably the only way he would sign for us in the first place. You can't have it both ways.

[Bill]

That was probably the only way he would sign for us in the first place. You can't have it both ways.

I believe you can

[Ramsey is god]

I am sorry but these stats mean F all. I do not understand people raving about McCarthy. He was utter sh!te when played for us. A poor start at palace and once Speroni is back, he will be back on the bench. Was delighted with the fee we got for him

From memory it was Redknapp who signed him, so that's two managers who thought Green was a better option and i am going to agree with the people who seem them on a day to day basis.

[Ginger Ninja]

Don't rate Smithes

Thats a shocker.

[knocker]

Don't rate Smithes

If you've seen him play more than once, I would be amazed.

[Is Dom Is Good]

I am sorry but these stats mean F all. I do not understand people raving about McCarthy. He was utter sh!te when played for us. A poor start at palace and once Speroni is back, he will be back on the bench. Was delighted with the fee we got for him

From memory it was Redknapp who signed him, so that's two managers who thought Green was a better option and i am going to agree with the people who seem them on a day to day basis.

So a bloke that was dubbed the next english keeper was utter sh!te..more just that we didnt give him a chance and he never had any certainty about his spot, thus a lack of confidance

[Ginger Ninja]

So a bloke that was dubbed the next english keeper was utter sh!te..more just that we didnt give him a chance and he never had any certainty about his spot, thus a lack of confidance

No, he was shite.