Surrender Monkey's

[Kurt Bakholt]

I just feel that Charlie isn't a one season wonder, as a club we should his goals are our best chance to get promoted, if that means losing 10m, so be it, he's on low wages.
Would Pelle have scored as many goals as Charlie did for us, I doubt it, would Clyne have had five caps last season, I doubt it. So saying Clyne is worth more because Southampton finished 8th is rubbish.
So I would say to clubs, if you think he's a one season wonder, wait 'til next summer and you can have him for free, if not pay what City paid for Bony, Spurs paid for Saldado and Liverpool paid for Lallana, 25m not 10. And to Charlie enjoy your honeymoon and look forward to seeing you knuckle down, and help get the club you happily signed a 3 year contract with promoted, when you get back.

[Kevin Mcleod]

To all you dream team managers who say we should be grateful to get 8-10m for Charlie because he has a year left on his contract, who would you rather have playing for us next season, Clyne or Austin? What's the difference other than Saints know what their players are worth, and play hardball?

One is an england regular who will get fifty plus caps, the other one wont ever play a minute in an england shirt, maths is maths.

[Hove Ranger]

I just feel that Charlie isn't a one season wonder, as a club we should his goals are our best chance to get promoted, if that means losing 10m, so be it, he's on low wages.
Would Pelle have scored as many goals as Charlie did for us, I doubt it, would Clyne have had five caps last season, I doubt it. So saying Clyne is worth more because Southampton finished 8th is rubbish.
So I would say to clubs, if you think he's a one season wonder, wait 'til next summer and you can have him for free, if not pay what City paid for Bony, Spurs paid for Saldado and Liverpool paid for Lallana, 25m not 10. And to Charlie enjoy your honeymoon and look forward to seeing you knuckle down, and help get the club you happily signed a 3 year contract with promoted, when you get back.

I gave multiple reasons as to why clyne is worth more than charlie, the reference to finishing 8th was in regards to the fact they will be playing european football next year and are a prem team so his value will be more (unlike us who were relegated). Also most clubs wont buy a player because you feel he isnt a one season wonder unless you are involved in their recruitment process. They usually wait for it to be proven. But in all honesty they are completely different players with different backgrounds and the only similarity is that they both have 1 year left on their deals so the comparison is somewhat pointless

[Kurt Bakholt]

I hear what you're saying Hove, all I'm trying to say is in my opinion, keeping Charlie for one more season is a better option than 10m in the bank.

[Hove Ranger]

I hear what you're saying Hove, all I'm trying to say is in my opinion, keeping Charlie for one more season is a better option than 10m in the bank.

Thats fair enough mate. Then just say that, you're not alone, many fans agree with you. I think the owners will see it differently and will cash in on him and IMO thats the sensible business decision

[Kevin Mcleod]

I hear what you're saying Hove, all I'm trying to say is in my opinion, keeping Charlie for one more season is a better option than 10m in the bank.

Whole heartedly agree and im sure the money men at rangers do as well, but charlie wants prem football and its out of our hands so to speak.

[Guildford_R]

If Andy Carroll was worth 35m, Charlie is certainly worth 15m.

[Kurt Bakholt]

Charlie's contract say's it's certainly not out of our hands, unless I'm mistaken.

[Shepherds Mush]

If Andy Carroll was worth 35m, Charlie is certainly worth 15m.

To be fair, Carroll wasn't worth £35m and has never been worth £35m.......Liverpool were just stupid to spend that amount. To highlight how stupid they were, they paid £23m for Suarez !

[Kevster269]

If someone said we'd be guaranteed promotion for 15 million quid then I'm sure we'd snap their hand off so....keep Charlie for the last season of his contract and let him go on a free at the end of the season, effectively losing that 15 million (if indeed he is worth that). I really think he will be the difference between pushing for promotion and ####ing around in mid table.

[Kevin Mcleod]

Charlie's contract say's it's certainly not out of our hands, unless I'm mistaken.

Oh great, hes staying then.

[Kevin Mcleod]

If someone said we'd be guaranteed promotion for 15 million quid then I'm sure we'd snap their hand off so....keep Charlie for the last season of his contract and let him go on a free at the end of the season, effectively losing that 15 million (if indeed he is worth that). I really think he will be the difference between pushing for promotion and ####ing around in mid table.

I reckon swp must of earnt about that for doing absolutley so d all, so i doubt the money men care about the money if he would say he wanted to stay, but he doesnt im very sad to say.

[Kurt Bakholt]

Oh great, hes staying then.

If the club turn down all offers and sacrifice whatever fee we were offered, yes he would be staying and if I was Les that's what I'd advise the board to do.
I can't see that happening though, but it's not up to Charlie

[alanfullerqpr]

we just need to come out and say pay up or he plays for QPR next season also speak to Austin and say if noone comes in you are staying and offer him a bonus to stay