matt phillips and Ned next

[Buffalo]

I'm surprised at you of all posters 77 you and me and anybody with an ounce know these aren't quite the mark they flatter to deceive Oroura good but vastly over rated by many on here , Phillips really should have shown a lot more by now big disappointment I really thought he could be the dogs ,these player should have shown their quality in the ch/ship if they had what's required what ever manager or system played under but they never did certainly not consistently , H has seen enough and is putting his job on the line to meet this head on , he's not that stupid to not have other irons in the fire and good that he' showing some balls

Not really arguing as you may be right but the two players you mention are both young and have the potential to be very good players. Neither has really had a good run of games for us though so are bound to seem disappointing. I don't think Ned is "vastly overrated" by anyone but most can see that he could be a very good defender if he improves some aspects of his game.

[Ginger Ninja]

Don't want to see Phillips, Onuoha or Traore go. Incredibly short sighted if they do.

**** off Arry

Not too fussed about Simpson or Traore provided we have cover ready. But getting rid of Onuoha would be utter madness.

[West London is Rss]

Fair to say the sh1t will well and truly hit the fan if Simmo Traore and the Chief leave.

[Nick]

Would be amazed if Ned and Phillips go.

[West London is Rss]

Would be amazed if Ned and Phillips go.

Yet nothing amazes me with Rangers anyomore

[Fordy]

Traore id let go. Not good enough. End of. But the rest no way

[Nick]

Yet nothing amazes me with Rangers anyomore

Yeah fair point Rss, we've always been a bit of a lottery club when it comes to transfer windows.

[hh9]

Agree with this. Its not a bad time to roll the dice. All 4 are decent squad players but if we can replace them with 4 first teamers then we will be in a better situation. We dont have endless supplies of cash, some have to go before others come in.

there is a big IF in there
try to name a left footer who would want to play for QPR and at the right price

[dogsrrs]

Not really arguing as you may be right but the two players you mention are both young and have the potential to be very good players. Neither has really had a good run of games for us though so are bound to seem disappointing. I don't think Ned is "vastly overrated" by anyone but most can see that he could be a very good defender if he improves some aspects of his game.

No your'e not arguing you're casting a valid opinion but you say Ned could be a very good defender IF he improves some aspects of his game , but that word IF covers more than most other words , has H seen enough and doesn't see IF happening for him and Phillips ? after all he see's more of them than us believe me I would love to be wrong about Phillips that he could be as good as I thought he could it still shouldn't be potential as we haven't tme got to wait , remember TF has offered H a 2 year extension and he's willing to put that at risk so he must feel strongly about letting players go , assuming these stories are true

[Buffalo]

No your'e not arguing you're casting a valid opinion but you say Ned could be a very good defender IF he improves some aspects of his game , but that word IF covers more than most other words , has H seen enough and doesn't see IF happening for him and Phillips ? after all he see's more of them than us believe me I would love to be wrong about Phillips that he could be as good as I thought he could it still shouldn't be potential as we haven't tme got to wait , remember TF has offered H a 2 year extension and he's willing to put that at risk so he must feel strongly about letting players go , assuming these stories are true

Absolutely, and IF we can get some cash for them and IF we can use it to improve the squad, then I'm all for it. Would just be sentimentality otherwise.

I'm disappointed in Ned as I think he is a great defender except for the odd mistake. I'm not so disappointed with Phillips as he was unlucky last year with injury and still think he could be an asset for us. Anyway, they are still here for the moment.

[rainham r]

getting rid of the chief would be stupid as he can cover the entire back 4 or is it 5.anyone at burton will know that dunne is on his last legs and is now a championship player at best.danny simpson although it pains me to say it is also a championship full back.still think matty phillips has the potential to be a premier player.players we should have got rid of are henry and wright phillips but we were stupid enough to pay them riddiculous money thus making them hard to move while they are in contract.

[QPRDave]

Those getting their knickers in a twist .....you do realise there will be replacements lined up?...now get a mug of coco, settle down and enjoy the ride!!!

[gator]

Those getting their knickers in a twist .....you do realise there will be replacements lined up?...now get a mug of coco, settle down and enjoy the ride!!!

Exactly, that's all we can do! I would be sad go see Onouba go, as others have said he is a decent defender and versatile, we have to hope Harry and the board know what they are doing, what choice do we have? The Burton match may ha e done more good than bad in that it was the last straw and some of the under achievers have to be replaced!

[QPRDave]

Yeah agree gator...I too will be sad to see Ned go...

[MaineHoopsFan]

Behind the scenes Harry has a plan. He's cutting the fat off the pig. If our second squad cant beat Burton how are they going to jump in a game and make a difference?
Traore can leave. Not really sure what position he plays anymore, but he's not good at any of them. That's a harsh truth.
I like Nedum a lot, so it would take some serious cash (5m) to let me watch him go. He still has 5 years left in him.
Phillips im up in the air about. If we get around what we paid for him than he can go.
SWP will be here till his contract runs out. He will then join the New York Red Bulls and Score 40 goals next season, only being bested by BWP, Who will score 41.
Simpson can go. He came on a free and was solid last season, but if he couldn't cut it in Newcastle 2 years ago, then he surely cant cut it here.
HOILLET CAN GO- He is arguably the only winger in the world that cant cross the ball into the box in the air. Shameful.
Dunne can go but wont, nobody wants him
Adel will stay till atleast Jan and save at least one match for us in that time (Bold Prediction!)
Karl Henry can go. He should've left with the other 30+ from last season.

Yun can stay, get healthy, and be a great wingback. He is more of an attacking back.
Petrasso and Sutherland needs a couple games off the bench if they haven't been loaned out.