Tom Carroll

[QPRDave]

Would you like to see him join on a permanent deal?....The Championship really didn't suit him, too much hustle and bustle, but the Prem might be more his style.
Plus in the Champs, we were everyone's cup final and it was a case of every game was a war

[Factamondo]

tough one dave...........is he better bet than ale......prob not!

[qblockoompah]

I'd take him but not as a starter so wouldn't spend much

[W12_Ranger]

I would want a discount in my ST if we signed Carroll perm

[QPRWEBBIE]

Sorry too lightweight and prem midfielders would eat him alive

[Tarbie]

Not a chance for me.......wouldn't come cheap and decent games were few and far between during his loan!

[Brightsparx]

Rather nick Livermore from hull gasp

[californiahoop]

Not for me, something seems to be missing with the kid, can only function in a five man midfield, needs protection in order to perform.

[californiahoop]

Rather nick Livermore from hull gasp

That's a shout and a half!

[QPRDave]

Yet our manager and Sherwood, among others really rate him, what are we missing?

[Factamondo]

Rather nick Livermore from hull gasp

surely jake is better!

[Busheyboy]

he'll never put up any trees

we can get better players in than him

if we can get Ali F back to his best, that would be like having a new player (VERY BIG IF!)

[West Acton]

Looked a better side once he was dropped and performances picked up so that's a no from me

There will be better players about who will be cheaper and offer more

[californiahoop]

If HR truly rated him he would have played him more when it counted!

[QPRDave]

If HR truly rated him he would have played him more when it counted!

Good point