How will Harry play it?

[Yousef]

Matt Phillips has just got back to training so no way he will be involved. If I was Harry I would field the most exprienced players I have, preferably who have played in at Wembley before. My starting XI:

Green

Simpson Onuoha Hill Traore (Yun)

O'Neil Barton Henry Hoilett

Kranjcar (Morrison)

Auston Zamora (Doyle)

[geejaybee]

A penalty waiting to happen.

One of my main concerns for Saturday,is that HR plays Dunne and that this will be exploited by Derby in the guise of Chris Martin who was born in Suffolk from the same mould as Grant Holt.Martin is a big,quick physical lump,who not only scores a goal every other game,but is second only to Tom Daley when it comes to "diving".Google is full of incidents where Martin has gone over far too easily,and I just hope the ref is alert enough to spot his cheating.

[qprdel]

Agree. Think Dunne could be a liability on such a large pitch.

[Yousef]

I keep saying Dunne should be on the bench. Cannot risk his defensive mistakes. He is slow and can easily commit a penalty.

[suttonranger]

The one he got booked for Wigan away was it actually a foul? I only saw it real time and didn't think it was and bloke made a meal of it.

I know dunne is slow but he does have tonnes of experience as long as he doesn't let people get past him

[Yousef]

The one he got booked for Wigan away was it actually a foul? I only saw it real time and didn't think it was and bloke made a meal of it.

I know dunne is slow but he does have tonnes of experience as long as he doesn't let people get past him

The picth at Wembley is large so If anyone gets past him, he will never catch him.

[Olly]

Wembley is the same width as ours, just more space around it.

[Bluehoop]

How many pens has Dunne conceded this season?
How much bigger is the pitch at Wembley than at Loftus Road?
The one he got booked for against Wigan was not a foul at all, he got the ball 100% with no contact and the Wigan player did what Wigan players do = dived and rolled around and coned the ref
If I'm being honest I want Hill at CB alongside the Chief and Yun at left back - but if H goes with Dunne then so be it because if the OP thinks about it he will find that his concerns are somewhat false, other than built on message board perceptions and the fact it has been a long season for the old bloke at the back

[Brian Wilson]

He played well in both playoff legs. Deserves his place.

[Johnny Tightlips]

When I read the OP title, I assumed Mbia and Diakite were back. Thank **** for that

[Tamworthram]

Agree with your comments about Martin going down too easily (I saw Rams fans at Leeds with "Chris Martin school of diving" T-shirts) but he's not that fast just good at holding up the ball, laying it off, falling over - oh, and scoring goals. Not sure who our best speed merchant is, probably Russell.

I reckon our team will be;

Grant
Wisdom Keogh Buxton Forsyth
Bryson Kendrick Thorn
Russell Martin Ward

Depending on how the game goes used subs will probably be out of Hughes, Dawkins, Eustace, Bamford and Sammon

[zeberdee]

Speed is only one aspect else Usain Bolt would be a footballer and all a scout would need is a stopwatch ans starting pistol
Dunne didn't concede penalties in either game vs Derby and has played every game in one of the best defences in England this season and did great in the last 2 games vs Wigan.
Bad scenarios are easy to dream up and it is the goalscoring ones that concern me more than the defence tbh.

[maidstone_hoop]

Harry will def pick dunne imo. Its I think its the lb position thats up for discussion. Really wouldnt be suprised if we do something similar like we did again wigan. Hill plays 50 odd minutes keeps it tight and then bring yun to up the anti.

Cant see henry playing at all

Oneil Barton kranjar hoilett

Moirrsion

Austin

I personally would go with that - I really think we have the better footballers and if we can get kranjar and morrison in the game we will certainly create chances.

[Jeems]

Green
Simpson, Dunne/Hill, Onuhua, Yun
Yossi Barton O'Neil, Hoilett
Niko
Austin

Ravel and Zamora to come on and batter them after 70mins.

[Del]

Matt Phillips has just got back to training so no way he will be involved. If I was Harry I would field the most exprienced players I have, preferably who have played in at Wembley before. My starting XI:

Green

Simpson Onuoha Hill Traore (Yun)

O'Neil Barton Henry Hoilett

Kranjcar (Morrison)

Auston Zamora (Doyle)

That line up has too many players.....