Tom Carroll is Pony ......

[FurtiveFox]

Just too lightweight. Particularly with the way 'Arry likes to play we need someone stronger. Henry alongside Barton would be more effective. Win ball, give to someone else.

[winalotto]

Get rid !!!!!! Stop bringing him back in to the midfield , he hoofs it in the air or goes missing in the games

Wow Tom Carroll just hoofs the ball , my word what an observation that is....

[Factamondo]

im sorry but the kid is too lightweight in the rough tough world of championship football.....as much as it makes me a hypocrite diakite shouldve been given half a dozen games to see if he could add anything to a totally uninspiring midfield!

[winalotto]

We all see different games , but he is not a hoofer

[stanistheman]

How often does Carroll win tackles? How many goals had he scored or created?

I don't think he should be in the team and would rather Redknapp played some of QPR's youngsters rather than Carroll. I would also have preferred Diakite to have been given a chance. He played against Swindon and at times looked decent and other times poor, but given that was his 1st appearance in 6 months or so, it was unfair to expect a good consistent performance.

Yes, Jenas is better and has done more in his appearances than Carroll.

[Factamondo]

agree stan id start jenas ahead of carroll!

[Tarbie]

Yeah, tried to look for positives with Carroll for a while but the fact is he's just cack!

[Bluehoop]

If he is, what does that make the collection of hopeless individuals employed directly by Rangers that masquerade as midfielders

[toptop]

why the hell do we play loan players and get them match fit then leave our own youngsters to bench warm or play in the reserves. We need to give youth a chance.

Early on in the season i really thought we would with tom hitchcock scoring that winner. such a shame really but skapetis, sharif, hitchcock all talented and no chances given to them. whilst BAE, zamora, niko, benayoun, phillips etc all given chances.