Dave Mac's player ratings

[Stanley]

It was a frustrating night in front of goal for QPR, but a point was enough to take them to the top of the Championship. Here’s how we rated the players in their 0-0 draw at home to Brighton: http://www.westlondonsport.com/featu...player-ratings

[WeAreQPR12]

Don't agree D mac. Henry would be lucky to get a 5 from me.

I could of driven back to surrey and had a shower before the bloke fu***** released the ball. Gives us nothing going forward and it seems to encourage other players to pass back wards and sideways.

[CroydonCaptainJack]

I quite liked the comparison of BAE with Clive Wilson.

[Kevin Mcleod]

Haven't clicked it, did my own ratings and not one player on the pitch deserved anything over a 5.

[CroydonCaptainJack]

Haven't clicked it, did my own ratings and not one player on the pitch deserved anything over a 5.

I'll stick with Dave Macs then. So BAE didn't warrant more than a 5?

[WeAreQPR12]

I'll stick with Dave Macs then.

Jack is that you in your avatar? I didn't know you were just a boy. Apologies for arguing in the past.

[Kevin Mcleod]

Been through the Moose for talksports tweets from last night, he's well matey with cinzano and Taylor, and he was saying it was a terrible game, all he wanted to do was go home, but cos he was being paid to be there he couldn't.
He still thinks we will go up though. (like I do)

[CroydonCaptainJack]

Jack is that you in your avatar? I didn't know you were just a boy. Apologies for arguing in the past.

No WeAre it is my youngest lad. He met Harry before the open day a few weeks back and my wife wife took the pic. He sent it in to Match magazine and it was published this week so he was made up.

Carry on arguing away mate as I am nearly 50!!

[MattyRangers]

Don't agree D mac. Henry would be lucky to get a 5 from me.

I could of driven back to surrey and had a shower before the bloke fu***** released the ball. Gives us nothing going forward and it seems to encourage other players to pass back wards and sideways.

Really? IMO he was in the top 3 best players for us. I'd go as far as to say he made more succesful forward passes than most of the team n all.

[Ginger Ninja]

agree with all of those ratings. dunne was MOM for me, an absolute brick wall.

[QprSinceBirth]

"was playing well before having to go off. " so he gives nedum a 6 because he got injured then i take it?

[Bluehoop]

Simply can't take DM seriously. Joey Barton got an 8 on the basis that his passing was very good. No it wasn't, he gave the ball away countless times. Not picking on Barton so much as pointing out why DM is clueless. JB's dead ball delivery was good and warranted a reasonable mark but seriously, 8 on the basis of his passing. LOFL.
BAE also got an 8. That's all based on reputation and the fact that he does ooze premier league class. It does not reflect his performance on the night. He miss hit a couple of crosses, gave the ball away a few times and allowed the opposition to get in behind him as well. He also did not bomb on at all in the fashion he did so for Spurs. When he's fit and finds his feet he will probs be an 8+ every game but honestly, you can't give someone 8 out of 10 because they are a quality player even when they don't particularly shine.
I'd love to know when Green was slow coming off his line? He was faultless in the little he had to do - DM gave him the right mark, albeit by luck rather than judgment.
He got one thing right though - mind you, you don't need to be an expert to notice that Dunne is like a brick wall. Another quality performance from him and he is clearly not a slow donkey like several people suggested when we signed him