Who would you keep from the following

[Yousef]

Most of us agree that the following players are either underperforming mercenaries, past their best or perhaps good players but our tactics did not help them show their best:

Mbia
Bosingwa
Park
Hoillet
Granero
Cisse
Samba
SWP

If you were given the choice to keep anybody of them, who would you keep?

[Pey]

A well dedicated to the course, fully fit and concentrated Cisse would be deadly in the Championship.
However his problems in the personal environment, obsessive nature with lifestyle and a troubled relationship with Harry it won't happen.

[vblockranger]

Most of us agree that the following players are either underperforming mercenaries, past their best or perhaps good players but our tactics did not help them show their best:

Mbia
Bosingwa
Park
Hoillet
Granero
Cisse
Samba
SWP

If you were given the choice to keep anybody of them, who would you keep?

Hoilett and Cisse and SWP if they can be motivated.

[3London]

Samba
SWP

[Ginger Ninja]

Hoilett, Samba and SWP.

[W12hoops]

Samba
Hoillet
Granero

[maverick69]

Hoillet and Samba - provided they were both fully fit....... which I don't think they were last season.

The rest can Foxtrot Oscar

[Rangers77]

Hoillet and Samba - provided they were both fully fit....... which I don't think they were last season.

The rest can Foxtrot Oscar

These two. Get rid in January if they're as pants as they were last season. Toilet has to know he's in the last chance saloon.

[OneEyedWilly]

Most of us agree that the following players are either underperforming mercenaries, past their best or perhaps good players but our tactics did not help them show their best:

Mbia
Bosingwa
Park
Hoillet
Granero
Cisse
Samba
SWP

If you were given the choice to keep anybody of them, who would you keep?

Samba & Hoilett

[Tarbie]

Most of us agree that the following players are either underperforming mercenaries, past their best or perhaps good players but our tactics did not help them show their best:

Mbia
Bosingwa
Park
Hoillet
Granero
Cisse
Samba
SWP

If you were given the choice to keep anybody of them, who would you keep?

If the opportunity was there to offload them and get the bulk of what we have spent on them back I would offload the lot. In fact there are probably a few other players like Young, Zamora, Traore, Barton and Johnson that I would add to that list.

Realistically I would expect to see SWP & Samba here next season, neither have done well enough to attract clubs that would be prepared to match what they are earning here (and in Samba's case, the transfer fee too). Remains to be seen as to whether anyone else is daft enough to buy Park (with his knackered knee), knowing that he comes with some earning potential in terms of marketing in the Far East.

The rest of the list I think will go in the summer.

[Norths]

None

[Greg1882]

Samba is a good cb regardless of what people say , dunno what was up with him last year but we will see his ability this year for sure . Hoilet is also a decent player but not sure if the attitude is right . I genuinely think swp would be decent on the championship too so I'd take a punt on those three . Everyone else can do one

[Yousef]

Samba is a good cb regardless of what people say , dunno what was up with him last year but we will see his ability this year for sure . Hoilet is also a decent player but not sure if the attitude is right . I genuinely think swp would be decent on the championship too so I'd take a punt on those three . Everyone else can do one

Samba admitted himself he was not fully fit when he joined us!

[Greg1882]

Samba admitted himself he was not fully fit when he joined us!

There is defiantly a good player in there somewhere mate .

[Ginger Ninja]

There is defiantly a good player in there somewhere mate .

agree, samba is mustard, he didnt show it last season. in the championship, with a full pre season behind him, 100% fit, he would be an absolute rock.