Many Redknapp fans on here but lets put it this way...

[WeAreQPR12]

what would you rather?

a)Keep adel and let him tear the league up and guarentee our promotion back to the premier league and bring in a new manager that know's how to get the best out of him or b)stick with Harry who will probably want to sell him.

Adel over Harry for me any day of the wk.

Clearly both don't work together.

[vblockranger]

Stick with Harry...all day long

[West Acton]

Keep Harry without doubt

Think Adel has promised much but delivered very little in two years in the top flight. One outstanding season in the Championship but has never built on that. Undoubted talent but dont think you will see him go to the next level until hes playing in a team that has better players which can accomodate him.

[Hitman34]

then you wonder why no one under the age of 40 takes any notice of you lmfao. what a thread.

[bmthranger]

I,m a fan of both, but adel needs to find some consistency and loose a bit of weight, that way he might win Arry over, adel is great to watch on his day but for me, and I,m no expert he is lazy when things don't go right for him, that's when you need a bit more from him....

[Brian Wilson]

HARRY

[rickyranger]

what would you rather?

a)Keep adel and let him tear the league up and guarentee our promotion back to the premier league and bring in a new manager that know's how to get the best out of him or b)stick with Harry who will probably want to sell him.

Adel over Harry for me any day of the wk.

Clearly both don't work together.

Is this even a serious question, there is no way Tarrabt would have the same effect on a season again, even in the Championship. It only happened because Warnock and all the players put aside their true feelings to accommodate him, no other manager or set of players would repeat that.

[QPR71]

you say adel would guarantee promotion....but there is no guarantee

[QPRDave]

'Arry all the way weare, not sure Adel will have the same effect he had before on the championship.......we need a team.........not rely on one man cause he'll just get snuffed out of every game....only your opinion that 'Arry will sell him, and i don't think you can guarantee promotion either

[Bigdave]

I think when Adel is at his most ruthless, when he is direct, Redknapp would play him every week. Its the times when Adel f u cks about with the ball and delivers no end product, and we have seen plenty of games like that this season, that gives Redknapp the #######ache.

[WeAreQPR12]

you say adel would guarantee promotion....but there is no guarantee

some people clearly have short memorys and yes he would destroy the championship again, he is far to gifted not too and makes some of the championship defenders look like pub players.

[MYU]

you say adel would guarantee promotion....but there is no guarantee

Agree... one man don't make a team. If we do go down I think Harry would play Adel if he stayed?

[WeAreQPR12]

Agree... one man don't make a team. If we do go down I think Harry would play Adel if he stayed?

He might want to play him but he doesn't know how to play him. He needs to be given a free role

[OneEyedWilly]

zero guarantee when it comes to taarabt...harry for def.

[West Acton]

some people clearly have short memorys and yes he would destroy the championship again, he is far to gifted not too and makes some of the championship defenders look like pub players.

He was great but that dont automatically mean it will happen again. Torres was great when he came to the England he is pony now you cant guarantee anything

When were doing well in the championship all he done was talk about moving to a bigger club, when we came up he spoke about moving to a bigger club so if we go down I would expect him to want to leave and fair play to him if he does.