Goalkeeper v Villa

[HoopDoggyDogg]

If Green is fit, do ya think Harry will bring him back or stick with McCarthy?
Harry will probably bring back Green, but I hope McCarthy has his chance for a while now as looks a good keeper.

[vespa]

i`d give McCarthy a chance to prove himself ,we all know Greens failures and good points and knowing he has to fight to get his place back wont do him any harm
( he has shown good character in the past )_

[rodman]

McCarthy.

Looked a hundred times more confident between the sticks than Green ever does.

Had no chance for any of the goals, pulled off a couple of good saves and actually CAME OFF HIS LINE on more than one occasion to deal with crosses / corners etc.

McCarthy for me.

[Factamondo]

lets let them fight for their place ala clemence/shilton in the 70,s!

[lymehoop]

should keep the same team and make amends for throwing away 3 points

[bushcelt1]

Tbh i would start with the same team as the liverpool one. If barton is fit i would give him a role in the 2nd half when sandro tires. Junior to come on instead of phillips. Vargas to come on early in the 2nd half.

[dave58]

the team shouldn't change other than injuries, hopefully the chief is ok otherwise it means Harry gets the chance to bring back Rio which one of us want?

[bakes8]

McCarthy has the shirt and has done nothing wrong to lose it. Bloke looks like a top top class keep. Hope we nailed him down to a zillion year contract.

[Jimmy Floyd Rabbit]

McCarthy.

Although Green not a bad keeper he's not particularly special. Also doesn't fill me with much confidence.

McCarthy young, hungry with all to prove. He's our future not Rob Green.

[Shepherds Mush]

Keep McCarthy in and therefore make Green work hard in training to win back his place.

Didn't really do much wrong against Liverpool IMO

[MINCER]

McCarthy needs to follow Adels diet and visit Joeys hairdresser as he reminds me of the great Phil Parkes in stature.

[West London is Rss]

Greeno taking a bit of a tonking... Harry will still pick him.

[Ginger Ninja]

Harry will pick Green.

[acricketer]

Green. Mac let 3 goals in on Sunday.

[72bus]

Tbh i would start with the same team as the liverpool one. If barton is fit i would give him a role in the 2nd half when sandro tires. Junior to come on instead of phillips. Vargas to come on early in the 2nd half.

sounds good as long as we don't get any injuries