Redknapp: the WATRB populus verdict

[Geng]

I'm in the 'none of the above' camp btw. I never had any faith in HR in the first place: http://www.wearetherangersboys.com/f...e-SWP-Park-etc

Harry - the managerial equivalent of Bosingwa, Cisse, SWP, Park etc

No?

A guy with a reasonably successful career at a top club, involved in the Champions League, trophy-winner.

Drops down to little old QPR, for probably the last big contract of his career.

Who am I talking about here? The above applies to Bosingwa, SWP, Park, Cisse etc, but it also applies to Redknapp.

If we think the problem with our current squad is the amount of overpaid mercenaries, who see QPR as a last payday and, having once played at the top of the table, can no longer be arsed breaking a sweat to ensure we finish 12th rather than 18th....

...then why doesn't that same argument apply to our manager?

...so this doesn't particularly surprise me. But sacking him now would be daft. I'd like to see him go in the summer though, whatever division we're in. He's clearly not in this for anything other than the immediate short term, and I'd rather we appointed someone who wants to be at the club in five years time. I reckon he might walk anyway - would he really want to end his career with a relegation? He must know our squad would get torn to shreds in the PL. Worst case scenario is probably TF giving him 30m to spunk on his mates from Spurs class of '09, and then us getting relegated anyway.

[Geng]

1) Not biased if one ever studied the arcane art of arithmetics: compare the sum of votes on answers 1 , 2, 3 to the number of votes on answer 4.
2) Make your own poll that would not seem biased to you, who is stopping you Here is a tip: "Do I want Harry to stay?"
1. Passionately
2. Rather, yes
3. Perhaps

the poll doesn't quite work as it your opinion on HR commits you to calling for immediate action. I think the guy is a total charlatan but I certainly don't see the point in sacking him right now.

[supahoopsaaa]

Went for the closest option of keeping til the end of the season. No point changing now.

[Olly]

Not voted, this is a very biased poll. Kirill, you should know better!!!

Option 4 doesn't need the tailing remark.
Option 5 should be 'Should see out his contract'

[tetters]

Where's the 'best manager in the division' choice. That one.

[Kevin Mcleod]

1) Not biased if one ever studied the arcane art of arithmetics: compare the sum of votes on answers 1 , 2, 3 to the number of votes on answer 4.
2) Make your own poll that would not seem biased to you, who is stopping you Here is a tip: "Do I want Harry to stay?"
1. Passionately
2. Rather, yes
3. Perhaps

Ive already done a harry in or out poll, and its biased cos you didnt out an option of 'hes doing a fine job and if he gets us up lets give him a chance in the premiership'..

[ollyhoops]

I don't think he's right for QPR, but I want him to stay until the end of the season and then change.

[Factamondo]

as stated by some...let him go in the summer and replace with a young upwardly mobile manager.....redknapp has built his career on being media friendly yet what has he really achieved seeing that he has often spent vast sums in the transfer market????.....the lad robinson at mkdons hs been mentioned but again it would be a big risk.....if malkay mackay is available be worth a punt or the lad at brentford who i understand is very highly rated!

[Kevin Mcleod]

If stoke go down and sack hughes, and we go up or even stay down, id like to get hughes back. hes got to be better than the toss pot we have in charge now. *

[Nick]

A bit of a bias poll!

Yep just another p00 thread.

Ask yourself this... if we were top and unbeaten would this thread have started in the first place?... just put it in the "harry out" thread, along with many bore... I mean more.

[Harryboy]

Bad business not calling remy back we would be so far ahead in the league if he was in the team then everyone would call him sir Harry

[Jogo]

We have the best squad in the division but Harry is too negative. It is his fault but would wait and see at the end of the season.

[WeAreQPR12]

Where's the 'best manager in the division' choice. That one.

I suggest Kirill also adds 'deluded fan'

[Mattyqpr]

I can't say I've ever been happy with the job he's done here.

My biggest negative about Harry is, he seems to have his favourites and will continue to play them no matter what, (O'Neil, Carroll, Niko). Massively disappointed by his tactics too. Personally I think we would have walked this league if we played with wingers, whether it be 2 up front or 1, yet time and time again he's played O'Neil and Niko in wide areas.

He has to stay until the end of the season though, it would be terrible for the club to sack him now. If we don't go up, I think the best option would be to get rid and bring in Malky Mackay. If we go up, I'd be happy to stick by Harry.

[Mattyqpr]

Bad business not calling remy back we would be so far ahead in the league if he was in the team then everyone would call him sir Harry

Don't be stupid! Do you think for one second Remy wants to play in the Championship?